How is human existence "all for nothing"? My wife and children's and friends' existence is not all for nothing. Their existence everything to me, and if one's existence is everything to just one, then their existence cannot be all for nothing. — Harry Hindu
No offense, but I was looking for the thoughts of people who are familiar with this particular issue. — Tate
it is fitting to be sad to recognize that bothering to live is pointless. — Chisholm
Since there can be no end external to one's entire life, since one's life includes all of one's ends, life as a whole cannot have a point — Chisholm
I'll put you down for "I don't understand the question." — Tate
We are familiar with the issue. It's just we've solved the issue. It's not our problem you don't like, or understand, the solution. If you can't answer my question, then maybe you should put yourself down as not understanding the question or the issue. It sounds like you're regurgitating a mass delusion that human existence is meaningless.No offense, but I was looking for the thoughts of people who are familiar with this particular issue. — Tate
It sounds like you're regurgitating a mass delusion that human existence is meaningless. — Harry Hindu
The Universe doesn't hand out meaningfulness. It just is, and we are part of it. — Bitter Crank
it makes sense for us to want our acts, efforts, projects, and enterprises to have a point. — Chisholm
The Universe doesn't hand out meaningfulness. It just is, and we are part of it. Though considerable effort over time I have come to the conclusion that life is meaningless, but that isn't a terrible thing, It means that we can provide a measure of meaning in our own lives--by doing meaningful, as Banno said.
We are here for a short time; some as little as 15 minutes, others as many as 115 years. As we age and get smarter, there is less time left to exist. Time is shorter. At 75, I figure the end of my life is maybe just around this or the next corner.
I'm happier now than I have ever been. I'm busy, I'm reading a lot of history. I listen to great music on the radio and internet. There's the small house and weedy lawn to look after.
Death, like an over-flowing stream
Sweeps us away; our life is but a dream,
an empty tale, a morning flower
cut down and withered in an hour. — Bitter Crank
A point is a valued end and since we humans are agents, it makes sense for us to want our acts, efforts, projects, and enterprises to have a point. Valued ends provide justifying reasons for our acts, efforts, projects, and enterprises. Ends lie separate from the acts and enterprises for which they provide a point (e.g., you build a hut because you value the shelter provided by the hut and you value the shelter because you value yourself and others). Since there can be no end external to one's entire life, since one's life includes all of one's ends, life as a whole cannot have a point. This doesn't mean that the acts, efforts or projects within a life can't have a point.... But life as a whole, which is a separate effort and enterprise of its own, cannot.
Since we live our lives and structure our living-a-human-life efforts both in parts and as a whole, it is fitting to be sad to recognize that bothering to live is pointless. — Chisholm
You know dealing with our pain, our suffering, while well-intentioned often only prolongs it. Rather, a slight turn of the mind toward consent may have the effect of extinguishment. — ArielAssante
Does the word 'legacy,' hold any importance to you? — universeness
That depends on how you define meaning. If meaning is the relationship between cause and effect then meaning is innate to the universe. In asking what the meaning of life is you are asking what caused life to exist and what purpose (which is just another type of cause as a prediction of future states based on one's goal in the present (final cause)) it has.To be fair, I think the question refers to there being no innate meaning to the universe. — Jackson
Not to me, but I know that's the answer that some come to. Brian Green said he went into physics because he came across Camus, I think, as a young person — Tate
If meaning is the relationship between cause and effect then meaning is innate to the universe. — Harry Hindu
I'm more interested in why you don't think that, not that you actually don't think it. — Harry Hindu
Why don't you try answering the question about what people are asking when they are asking what the meaning of life is. What is meaning? — Harry Hindu
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.