• Isaac
    10.3k


    I prefer Spike Milligan's

    Join the Army! See the world. Meet new people... And kill them.
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    Joining the military is a HUGE gambleBitter Crank

    And the conscription officer goes "just the kinda person we wuz lookin'for! Welcome to the army."

    Wanting to be a soldier is exactly the kinda mindset one needs to be a good soldier! Oui?
  • ToothyMaw
    1.3k
    And the conscription officer goes "just the kinda person we wuz lookin'for! Welcome to the army."

    Wanting to be a soldier is exactly the kinda mindset one needs to be a good soldier! Oui?
    Agent Smith

    Actually, yes, I do think that those who want to be soldiers are often the best cut out for it. But not always. I specifically remember a kid I ate lunch with in high school talking about how he couldn't wait to join the military and kill some {insert pejorative often used against Arabs}. Pretty sickening, but not representative of those who want to be soldiers.
  • jgill
    3.9k
    Joining the military is a HUGE gambleBitter Crank

    It depends on how you join. I was sent to the U of Chicago for twelve months to be certified as a meteorologist (weather officer), all expenses paid plus salary, housing allowance, etc., never wore a uniform. Two and a half more years of not unpleasant duty and out, receiving an automatic GS11 rating should I want to join the Weather Bureau. I have a friend, now a district attorney, who was sent to law school, everything paid for plus salary, etc.,and rose to colonel in the Judge Advocates office. Another friend was sent to medical school to become an MD, all expenses paid plus salary, served a short period an left the service for private practice.

    Then there were those inducted during the Vietnam War. There's your HUGE with bells on it.
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    Actually, yes, I do think that those who want to be soldiers are often the best cut out for it. But not always. I specifically remember a kid I ate lunch with in high school talking about how he couldn't wait to join the military and kill some {insert pejorative often used against Arabs}. Pretty sickening, but not representative of those who want to be soldiers.ToothyMaw

    Soldiers, to my reckoning, are like pro-choicers: they must kill but not murder! Tough call, many/most fail; sic vita est.
  • ToothyMaw
    1.3k
    many/most failAgent Smith

    You are obviously trying to be a douche. The vast majority of soldiers are not murderers and should not be treated like murderers. Unless they actually murdered someone. Then of course their military status is nothing to hide behind.

    Your likening of soldiers to pro-choicers is kind of odd. Being pro-choice is a political position, whereas being a soldier is a job. The pro-choicer doesn't have to kill if they don't want to, but a soldier might have to kill even if they don't want to. The soldier follows orders, the pro-choicer just gets triggered.

    And the stereotypical philosophy forum douche accents their inane contributions with French and Latin expressions instead of putting up quality posts.
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    You are obviously trying to be a douche. The vast majority of soldiers are not murderers and should not be treated like murderers. Unless they actually murdered someone. Then of course their military status is nothing to hide behind.

    Your likening of soldiers to pro-choicers is kind of odd. Being pro-choice is a political position, whereas being a soldier is a job. The pro-choicer doesn't have to kill if they don't want to, but a soldier might have to kill even if they don't want to. The soldier follows orders, the pro-choicer just gets triggered.

    And the stereotypical philosophy forum douche accents their inane contributions with French and Latin expressions instead of putting up quality posts.
    ToothyMaw

    :lol:

    I douche! You, just a wannabe douche!

    Anyway, you missed the point of my post. Soldiers have to tread a thin line between being heroes (defending people, a way of life, etc.) and becoming villains (war crimes). Hats off to soldiers all over the world! Tough bein' one!
12Next
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.