Somehow the single most powerful rocket fired from Gaza ever, that could destroy whole buildings, misfired and hit one of the few hospitals in Gaza. — ssu
rom what point of view was the video taken? Near the hospital? — flannel jesus
Wasn't Hamas and Islamic Jihad fighters killing every Israeli they could find and reach already highly inflammatory? Correction, they did take some prisoners to act as shields, hence they didn't kill everybody.The whole issue is highly inflammatory, and there's not a lot of point in fanning the flames, as if there's not enough people doing that already. — Wayfarer
And if WSJ reported a video that wasn't the hospital bombing, I'm definitely sure that there will be an outcry in the US if such a prestigious newspaper as WSJ would be spreading Hamas propaganda and anti-semitic vitriol. — ssu
Wasn't Hamas and Islamic Jihad fighters killing every Israeli they could find and reach already highly inflammatory? — ssu
Somehow the single most powerful rocket fired from Gaza ever, that could destroy whole buildings, misfired and hit one of the few hospitals in Gaza. — ssu
The noise that ingoing and out going artillery makes is different. And then the fireball seems to be rather big. There's ample videos that show the difference between air to ground ordnance and "Katjusha" rocket fire, that basically Hamas has. To me that looks like ordnance from an aircraft. And it surely doesn't look like a small rocket that they in Gaza use.But the video doesn't take position wrt whom is to blame. And its footage of the blast doesn't tell me much about whom cause the blast. — neomac
Of course not.Do you think my recommendation to 'avoid inflammatory language' amounts to propaganda? — Wayfarer
I would question why the vitriol over just one attack, and not the war itself.Considering the amount of vitriol already sorrounding this issue, I'm simply advising moderation in speech. — Wayfarer
Yeah, that's why I find the most likely cause that Israel bombed the hospital and they are now rapidly making a media blitz (as @Tzeentch note they otherwise wouldn't do) to counter the public and diplomatic outrage as their most precious supporter, the US president, is coming to Israel just today.You're arguing impossibility, meaning Palestine couldn't have done this because their arsenal isn't capable of doing it. — Hanover
The noise that ingoing and out going artillery makes is different. — ssu
The noise that ingoing and out going artillery makes is different. And then the fireball seems to be rather big. — ssu
Just seems to me the most likely case here. — ssu
Aahh.. a bit difficult as videos usually taken are with hand held devices that don't have good sound recording. ButIt would be interesting if you could illustrate the different noise between "ingoing" and "outgoing" artillery through comparable videos. — neomac
I never called it (the audio) "authoritative". Nor affirmed my commitment to it. Taken in another sense, your claim sounds even contradictory. — neomac
And then also lie about it with "extremely fake" audios according to the most authoritative infowar experts on earth. Anyway, in today's day and age it's best to reserve judgement. — neomac
You indicated
And then also lie about it with "extremely fake" audios according to the most authoritative infowar experts on earth. Anyway, in today's day and age it's best to reserve judgement. — neomac
Your position was that there was authoritative evidence disproving the legitimacy of the evidence submitted by Israel in questioning the cause of the explosion. — Hanover
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.