Comments

  • Bidzina Ivanishvili
    I never said you were brainwashed, nor did I 'play you' (whatever that means).

    At most I suggested people in this thread were absorbing this information uncritically, exhibiting the reflexive, emotional response this type of media is meant to get out of them.

    Apparently that must have hit a nerve, since you immediately felt the need to label me a 'conspiracy nut' - another typical reflexive response.
  • Bidzina Ivanishvili
    Ah, gotcha. You are just another conspiracy nut such as the ones who assaulted the US Capitol building.javi2541997

    No clue where you got that idea.

    It's 2025. If the idea that media is designed to manipulate you is still news for you, then I don't know what to tell you. Get out from under your rock, I suppose.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    There's a reason the mustachioed gentleman referred to the extermination of the Jews as the final solution. Earlier attempts at deportation had failed.

    Such a peculiar set of footsteps Israel's hardliners are choosing to follow into.
  • Bidzina Ivanishvili
    As far as I can tell, this thread hasn't gotten far beyond gloating over the fate of some random oligarch, who is only being prosecuted because of the war in Ukraine and the western effort to erode Russian influence in Russia's (former) sphere of influence.

    We have oligarchs too, and they are much more influential (and cancerous) than this small fry. None of them are currently being prosecuted.

    Furthermore, I find it highly worrying to observe intelligent people being unable to see what is going on here:

    [...] , but Georgia's people deserve to vote on whether they want more proximity to the West or to Russia. Right?javi2541997

    This is exactly the type of reaction this media spin is meant to get out of you. "Poor Georgians, controlled by corrupt oligarchs, wouldn't it be nice if..."

    Aren't you getting a déjà vu moment right about now?

    This is exactly how western audiences were warmed up to the idea of Ukraine joining NATO.

    So I find myself obliged to mention that we are controlled by corrupt oligarchs too, and that they do not have our best interests at heart, nor that of the Ukrainians, nor that of the Georgians.

    Instead of absorbing information uncritically, one should ask "Why?" and "Why now?"
  • Bidzina Ivanishvili
    Whinging about other countries' oligarchs to distract from our own. Oh wait, we call them "billionaire philanthropists" here.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    The Bosnian Genocide

    Srebrenica Massacre

    Several high-profile individuals were tried and found guilty of genocide.

    You'll note that whether or not the genocide is successful is no factor. And you'll also note that a nation need not kill millions in order to be guilty of genocide. In the Srebrenica massacre 8,000 men were killed. This act was ruled unanimously an act of genocide in 2004, and the ruling was again upheld in 2007.


    Article II

    In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with
    intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group
    , as
    such:

    (a) Killing members of the group;

    (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

    (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its
    physical destruction in whole or in part;

    (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

    (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
    Convention on the Prevention of the Crime of Genocide


    Intent is of great importance here (which is why comparisons with Allied bombing during WW2 are moot). Unfortunately for Israel, several high-profile politicians have stated their genocidal intent outright and in public.

    This is why Netanyahu is currently wanted for crimes against humanity.

    All that's left is for the apologists to have their "Are we the baddies?" moment.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump has apparently barred any development of a US-based CBDC. I couldn't find much information on this particular decree. It seems most of the Media™ hasn't reported on it yet.

    Trump Kicks Crypto Policy into Gear and Hammers Nail in US CBDC Coffin

    That many nails may follow, and that this abomination of surveillance, financial repression and unrestrained currency devaluation may be thrown in the ocean never to resurface.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Only because the reasonable - and I will not debate the definition of 'reasonable' - people who have dared to speak out in public will have been silenced.Vera Mont

    Is this a prediction? Four years from now, no one will be speaking out in public against Trump because they will all have been silenced?

    Given the absolute deluge of criticism that Trump has received and is receiving I find that very hard to believe. But hey, if you're willing to make that prediction then we have at last found someone who is taking the premise of this thread seriously.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    However you refuse to back your point up by identifying what these evens of note might be.Tobias

    I've given you literally a blank check - 'fascism' can mean whatever you believe it means - and you still won't take the bet because you yourself evidently do not take the idea that the US may devolve into fascism of any description seriously either.

    And if you're expecting me to wade into details about something I don't take seriously to begin with then you are sadly mistaken.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?


    Now, I appreciate the fact that a 1000 Tzeentch-coins represents a substantial value, but you're sort of missing the point. I don't care what definition of fascism you use. Use your own made up definition if you want to.

    In four years no reasonable person will believe the US has become fascist by any definition of the word.
    Tzeentch
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Now you are shifting from 'nothng of particular note' to a whole country becoming fascist.Tobias

    'Shifting' :rofl: If you fail to grasp that in a thread about fascism I was talking in the context of fascism then that sounds like your problem to me.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Yes, obviously, but you seem to have a rather ... peculiar... notion of what that term means. you think that cutting the subsidies of a member of the club that frustrates the clubs overall policy amounts to ' looming fascism' whereas threatening military action against against entirely peaceful nations does not.Tobias

    I pointed not just to the EU's actions vis-á-vis Hungary, but at a wider trend in the EU, involving the fact that it is an untransparent, undemocratic, authoritarian den of nepotism and corruption, which makes it a likelier candidate to develop into fascism than the US - which isn't to say that it is likely that it will.


    Secondly, military action against peaceful nations is what the US does best. If you believe that shows the US is fascist, then it already is and has been for decades.

    The US invades and destroys other nations like its their national pastime. But the term for this is 'jingoism', not fascism. Fascism refers to how a state is organized, not to a foreign policy.


    Now, I appreciate the fact that a 1000 Tzeentch-coins represents a substantial value, but you're sort of missing the point. I don't care what definition of fascism you use. Use your own made up definition if you want to.


    In four years no reasonable person will believe the US has become fascist by any definition of the word.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Of course we have to settle on what 'of note' means.Tobias

    I'm talking about fascism, obviously. Or anything catastrophic that is beyond the scope of what is normal for US presidents and is directly attributable to Trump. Keep in mind that he'll have Biden to contend with in terms of wanton incompetence.


    It's routine for US presidents to ruin some part of the world for profit during their term, so don't yap about personal consequences.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Of course I'm not just talking about the Trump family. What rock have you been living under that you think oligarchy only became a thing under Trump?
  • US Election 2024 (All general discussion)
    Ah, right. No need to listen to anything they're saying, because we already know they're nazis. We've been told as much by the Media™, and they never lie to us about anything.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    You had better get used to that if you're intent on misrepresenting what I say or putting words in my mouth.
  • US Election 2024 (All general discussion)
    If you refuse to listen to what they actually say and only listen to their opponents, you're refusing to do your due diligence.
  • US Election 2024 (All general discussion)
    Did you watch the interview Musk did with Weidel?

    Was there anything in that interview that struck you as particularly nazi?
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    I called the EU a better example of looming fascism than the US, which you then tried to misconstrue as me calling the EU fascist according to a set definition.

    All I'll ask of you is to not put words in my mouth or deliberately take the things I say out of their context.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Nothing new under the sun. The US has been an oligarchy for decades, and it still is. It's just that the previous oligarchs have been ousted and they don't like the new ones, so we have to suffer through the whole sanctimonious melodrama.

    If anyone truly believed it was going to turn into something remotely fascist, I'm sure someone would have taken me up on my bet; predictably no one did, because all of them know they're just coping like disgruntled children, but unwilling to admit it.

    Hey I'm only going by your definition of fascism here. If you felt the need to call the EU "fascists" earlier then you should do the same for Trump as well. Either both are fascists or none are.Mr Bee

    I never gave my definition of fascism, nor did I call the EU fascist, but this is just a dumb argument to make.

    The EU is untransparent, overtly undemocratic and authoritarian. The unelected Queen Ursula has recently started her second term - a spot she only got because of her friendship with Merkel.

    This situation cannot be compared to the US, and obviously between the two if any are closer to fascism it is the EU by a mile and a half.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    This has been common practice in the US for decades. The only difference now is that the billionaires are not on the team you like, so suddenly it's fascism. :yawn:
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Trump said he’d end this war on day 1.Mikie

    A bit of a cheap gotcha, but ok.

    Let's say he ends the war in 100 days, as the Trump administration now says it intends, what then?

    Apparently all weapon shipments to Ukraine have been halted for the next 90 days.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    An aggressive foreign policy is nothing new for the US. It's not pretty, obviously, but it's not fascism in the way that it looms over the EU under the unelected Queen Ursula.

    Define what is "of particular note".ssu

    Fascism, obviously.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    I don't see how the two are remotely comparable.

    If you want to believe economic rivalry between two independent nations equals fascism then you've thrown all sense of reason and proportion out of the window.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    You're playing some victim card here now? Oof... You must be quite far gone.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    As they do under any president. Trump's first presidency was nothing special, no fascism, no World War 3, no end of days, etc. and I see no reason to believe his second will be any different.

    But by all means, believe the hysteria and propaganda. We'll see in four years. Take me up on my bet. There's a 1000 Tzeentch-coins in it if you win.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    Not sure if you've noticed, but your boy is currently wanted for crimes against humanity.

    That's a very exclusive little club he made himself, and by extension Israel, a part of.
  • Fascism in The US: Unlikely? Possible? Probable? How soon?
    Who'd like to take me up on a bet that in 4 years nothing of particular note will have happened, and you all are a bunch of hysterics?

    I bet a 1000 Tzeentch-coins on it.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    An unmitigated trainwreck is the only proper name for the Biden administration.

    It completely mishandled Ukraine and Gaza, and estranged half the world causing US power in the Persian Gulf and much of South-East Asia to all but collapse. It pushed Russia into the arms of the Chinese, and it pushed various influential countries to join the BRICS.

    It did all of this by exhibiting the same sense of self-importance and estrangement from reality as the people who are having a breakdown over Trump's second term.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Are you really defending Trump and his followers with that?Christoffer

    I'm defending no one. I'm scolding you lot.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The pretense that Trump is somehow uniquely bad, while categorically ignoring that the Biden administration was objectively an unmitigated trainwreck and probably among the worst of all time, is childish and suggests a delusional view of reality that is unbecoming of adults, let alone philosophically-inclined, intelligent people.

    And these people simultaneously fail to understand that they are part of the problem. America (and large parts of the world, for that matter) are done with them, and people like them, the ideas they uphold and their hypocrisy.

    The total lack of self-reflection amidst the moral whinging makes this collective mental breakdown even harder to watch.

    It's like watching children getting confronted with reality. But they throw a tantrum and there is no adult around to spank them.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    This forum is turning into a clownshow with all the adults whinging over a lost election. Jesus.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The Biden administration was 'involved' in the same way it has been 'involved' the last year - ceaseless groveling before the lobby and writing blank checks to Netanyahu in the vain hope it would lead to a Dem victory.

    The fact that Steve Witkoff was able to achieve this in a single sitting just goes to show how reluctant Biden was to put any meaningful pressure on Netanyahu.

    What is 'quite telling' is that in light of this you're still trying to give Biden credit, while unwilling to acknowledge Trump did a good thing.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Meanwhile, instead of continuing on Biden's policy of wanton destruction, Trump achieved a cease-fire in Gaza.

    I wonder if folks on this forum are able to acknowledge that, or if the cognitive dissonance would make their brains implode.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    You can say what you want about Trump, but by pressuring Israel into accepting a cease-fire his team has done more good in a single sitting than the Biden administration over its entire term.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    Well, it looks like the cease-fire is going to happen, and in my opinion this would clearly show that the Biden administration was simply reluctant to put any pressure on Israel whatsoever, likely in the hopes that stooging for the lobby would get the Dems re-elected.

    The Trump administration apparently was able to achieve more in a single sitting than the Biden administration over its entire term.

    Hopefully this will be the final nail on Netanyahu's coffin, and that will also be the only redeeming thing about the entire Biden administration. What a total disaster it has been.
  • Is China really willing to start a war with Taiwan in order to make it part of China?
    China will in all likelihood not resort to military means to incorporate Taiwan. It probably feels there is no immediate need to force the issue, and over time political options will become available to reach unification without bloodshed.

    However, if Taiwan were to declare its independence a Chinese intervention is all but a guarantee.
  • Crises of Modernity
    To put it quite simply, Western institutions have ran their course, and have now reached the terminal endpoint of any power structure, which is total delusion and corruption, and inevitable collapse.

    One glance at the clowns that are running the show in the West tells you all you need to know.

    The crisis is one of corrupt leadership, that has, in an effort to cling to its power and delusions, are increasingly painting the citizens of their countries as the problem.

    Fortunately, those are the death throes of a dying system, but unfortunately, it may take a couple more years before it finally dies.