Comments

  • Get Creative!
    ..and John. Those have a distinctive style. Makes me want to paint.
  • Get Creative!
    I really like your paintings Cavacava
  • Depression, and its philosophical implications
    The only odd question is why I'm the only one that has to justify myself (worth thinking about why that is).The Great Whatever

    I think you suffer your views to be challenged. You answer questions. You are capable of communication in a way that others find hard.

    I think Hume's idea that if you keep asking 'Well, what's good about that?' you eventually end up with pleasure = good and pain = evil is a very interesting and robust position. Despite it being very philosophically strong, for some reason many people don't like it or they don't think it true, so I guess people argue against it.

    I don't think I agree with it either, by the way, but I am nevertheless very sympathetic to TGWs Humean position.
  • Is the absurdity of existence an argument for god?
    1.) God does not exist, and therefore life is absurd.

    2.) Life is absurd without god, therefore god exists.
    darthbarracuda

    Rejigging these a bit:

    Argument 1:
    1. If there is no God, then life is absurd
    2. There is no God
    Therefore, life is absurd (MP)

    Argument 2:
    1. If there is no God, then life is absurd
    2. Life is not absurd
    Therefore, there is God (MTT)

    Both arguments are valid (unless I've got myself in a muddle). Are these what you had in mind darthbarracuda?
  • What is the expected formality on the new forum?
    I think there is also the fact that this is a brand new forum and members are excited and want to populate it with posts to 'get it going'. Once it's got going things might become a bit more focused on philosophy. Two things I think will help in this regard:
    1) Saving drafts (I often didn't post on PF because I couldn't post fast enough and couldn't be bothered to open a text file and start a post in that. Even when I did draft a post in a text file I often never got around to posting it as it sat gathering dust on my desktop).
    2) Having a regular paper of the month to read. Great idea.

    I wish I had more time to get stuck into the philosophy here.
  • Icon for the Site?
    SOCRATES.gif

    This is supposed to be Socrates. I guess the artist is emphasising his famed ugliness.

    I like Hypatia as well.
  • Gloucestershire Cheese Rolling
    Not yet. Incredibly it's still going. There was a 2015 race at least.
  • Help me test
    Looks nice to me. :) Aaah, we have saved drafts. That's good.