Medication + therapy first. Then philosophy. — darthbarracuda
I got pretty close to offing myself several years back, some people here might remember my first posts in the old forum...I didn't need philosophy, I needed a balanced neurochemistry. Thankfully I managed to get things more or less in line, though it took years. — darthbarracuda
Philosophy is only helpful if you have the capacity to form rational judgements of it, otherwise it's dangerous. Very easy to put people over the edge, after which they're liable to do something stupid and hurt themselves or someone else. It's why I try to be gentle to people online, even if they get on my nerves; you never know what they are going through and what role your words might play in their fate — darthbarracuda
Fingarette's work deals with issues in philosophy of mind, psychology, ethics, law, and Chinese philosophy...
Fingarette also influentially applied his work in moral psychology to pressing social and legal issues, particularly those surrounding addiction. In his 1988 book Heavy Drinking, Fingarette challenges the disease theory of alcoholism popularized by groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous.
Fingarette's arguments were employed by the U.S. Supreme Court in a 1988 decision to deny VA educational benefits to two alcoholic American veterans. — Wiki: Fingarette
but it says that the experiencing self seems different from Brahman, when in actuality it isn’t different. The seeming difference is the misidentification that must be overcome in order to achieve moksha (liberation). — Paul Michael
I never considered his personal philosophy much. I’m not really sure what that even is. He just got me wondering things like “what if God doesn’t exist?”
Do you still have him buried/burrowed in your head ?
— Amity
I don’t know what you mean exactly. I still like his music, at least his older stuff. — Pinprick
’m just a regular person with no such attainments to speak of. — Wayfarer
[My underlines]From what I understand, Advaita Vedanta is a school of Hindu philosophy which claims that all that exists is one pure consciousness, or what they call Brahman. Each individual, Atman, is identical to Brahman...
To me, Advaita seems to be a form of monistic idealism, an Rupert Spira has explicitly said as much in at least one of his YouTube videos. — Paul Michael
The essential philosophy of Advaita is an idealist monism, and is considered to be presented first in the Upaniṣads and consolidated in the Brahma Sūtra by this tradition.
According to Advaita metaphysics, Brahman—the ultimate, transcendent and immanent God of the latter Vedas—appears as the world because of its creative energy (māyā).
The world has no separate existence apart from Brahman.
The experiencing self (jīva) and the transcendental self of the Universe (ātman) are in reality identical (both are Brahman),though the individual self seems different as space within a container seems different from space as such.
These cardinal doctrines are represented in the anonymous verse “brahma satyam jagan mithya; jīvo brahmaiva na aparah” (Brahman is alone True, and this world of plurality is an error; the individual self is not different from Brahman). Plurality is experienced because of error in judgments (mithya) and ignorance (avidya). Knowledge of Brahman removes these errors and causes liberation from the cycle of transmigration and worldly bondage. — IEP: Vedanta, Advaita
Does Western philosophy comment on Advaita specifically? If so, what is the general consensus on Advaita in Western philosophy? — Paul Michael
The major metaphysical concepts in Advaita Vedānta tradition, such as māyā, mithya (error in judgment),vivarta (illusion/whirlpool), have been subjected to a variety of interpretations.
On some interpretations, Advaita Vedānta appears as a nihilistic philosophy that denounces the matters of the lived-world. — IEP: Vedanta, Advaita
The Advaita Vedānta ideas, particularly of 8th century Adi Shankara, were challenged by theistic Vedānta philosophies that emerged centuries later, such as the 11th-century Vishishtadvaita (qualified nondualism) of Ramanuja, and the 14th-century Dvaita (theistic dualism) of Madhvacharya.[293]
Advaita Vedānta and various other schools of Hindu philosophy share terminology and numerous doctrines with Mahayana Buddhism.[307][308] The similarities between Advaita and Buddhism have attracted Indian and Western scholars attention.[309][310] and have also been criticised by concurring schools. — Wiki: Advaita Vedanta
The perennial philosophy (Latin: philosophia perennis),[note 1] also referred to as perennialism and perennial wisdom, is a perspective in philosophy and spirituality that views all of the world's religious traditions as sharing a single, metaphysical truth or origin from which all esoteric and exoteric knowledge and doctrine has grown.
Perennialism has its roots in the Renaissance interest in neo-Platonism and its idea of the One, from which all existence emanates. Marsilio Ficino (1433–1499) sought to integrate Hermeticism with Greek and Jewish-Christian thought,[1] discerning a prisca theologia which could be found in all ages. [2]
Giovanni Pico della Mirandola (1463–94) suggested that truth could be found in many, rather than just two, traditions. He proposed a harmony between the thought of Plato and Aristotle, and saw aspects of the prisca theologia in Averroes (Ibn Rushd), the Quran, the Kabbalah and other sources.[3] Agostino Steuco (1497–1548) coined the term philosophia perennis.[4] — Wiki: Perennial philosophy
But learning to realise oneself as ‘pure consciousness’ takes more than grasping at the idea; probably something like, creating a mantra around it, and repeating it 10 million times, would be more like the traditionalists recommended methodology. — Wayfarer
Sorry, didn't see that in time. I wish Brexit could be solved with music — Olivier5
To live and not to breathe
Is to die in tragedy
To run, to run away
To find what you believe
And I leave behind
This hurricane of fucking lies
I lost my faith to this
This town that don't exist — Olivier5
Not sure I understand what you mean by 'never, not ever, again occupied'.
— Amity
Well, it is called "the fairy garden." It summons to me places and times of magic that belong to a child, but that an adult can only remember. But that's just me; how would you describe it? — tim wood
How does appreciation of Bruckner or a 'Manson' * enable anyone to appreciate themselves ?
— Amity
I'd answer, and not being evasive but I'm thinking you already know. — tim wood
Funny thing how 'zero attention' can change to 'deep appreciation'. Is it all in the timing ?
— Amity
It comes from a listening combined with an understanding of what's being heard. With Tony Bennett I simply had not understood, nor known enough to have cared. — tim wood
And hearing the Bach think little more about it - but it's a version of perfection the appreciation of which is gained through an open and attentive listening and also through the experience of imperfect or lesser versions. And there is a lot of this perfection in the world, though often realized in the mundane and the standardized and thus overlooked. And it strikes me - that I'll share with Amity as well - that appreciation of the other is also the other's enabling thee and me to appreciate ourselves. — tim wood
...it applies to all of Bruckner's symphonies. — tim wood
This apparent dichotomy between Bruckner the man and Bruckner the composer hampers efforts to describe his life in a way that gives a straightforward context for his music. Hans von Bülow described him as "half genius, half simpleton".[2] Bruckner was critical of his own work and often reworked his compositions. There are several versions of many of his works. — Wiki: Bruckner
I wonder if as with me "The Fairy Garden" pulls you back to rehear and re-listen. I hear in it a remembrance, a sad, yearning, but celebratory appreciation of magic lost. As if the garden were a living temple to lost sensibilities, to be visited but never, not ever, again occupied. — tim wood
...appreciation of music seems also about the music's enabling us to appreciate ourselves. — tim wood
Well, it’s partly just preference; I just so happen to enjoy this type of music, but I’m sure there’s also personal reasons. — Pinprick
Music, then, a kind of portal. There is its manifest surface, the sound, but also an invitation to enter, both as far as you like, and as far as the music will take you. My own bias no doubt shared by many, is that music that has stood at least some test of time keeps more of its promises as to what it offers. — @ tim wood
...he basically started me on the path to “philosophy” by questioning things I had taken as true. — Pinprick
Lift you up like the sweetest angel
I tear you down like a whore
I will bury your god in my warm spit
You'll be deformed in your porn — Amity
So, I’ll always be grateful for that — Pinprick
Well, his role as singer/musician seems to have inspired a few admirers ?But yeah, not exactly role model material. — Pinprick
10 years learning about philosophy - and you've learned what and from where ?
— Amity
Yeah, I was going to ask this but got sidetracked. — Tom Storm
Science is like being in a dark room looking for a black cat while using a flashlight.
If that's true, then philosophy is the instructions for using the flashlight. — T Clark
I took up an interest in philosophy about ten years ago, and since then I have learned a quite a bit; relatively speaking. — Bret Bernhoft
My own story of appreciation is about the singer Tony Bennett, in his 90s if still alive. I paid him zero attention - who cares about another lounge singer - until he published a series of collaborations with other popular singers. — tim wood
And it strikes me - that I'll share with Amity as well - that appreciation of the other is also the other's enabling thee and me to appreciate ourselves. — tim wood
Harb plays BWV 565, here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jtuTCy8RXg
An amazing performance. — tim wood
Well maybe ...
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2kGyunJd1D8 — 180 Proof
But, Manson’s “Deformography” worked well in the past — Pinprick
The Fairy Garden, from the Mother Goose suite
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5x-u7iw7W1Y
Bolero, of course, if a person isn't already tired of it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_pSJOkmYBA
Vltava (The Moldau), here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6kqu2mk-Kw
But the Moldau one of six tone poems in Ma Vlast. — tim wood
In a concert review, Bernard Holland described parts of the first movements of Bruckner's sixth and seventh symphonies as follows: "There is the same slow, broad introduction, the drawn-out climaxes that grow, pull back and then grow some more – a sort of musical coitus interruptus."[45] — Wiki: Bruckner
sometimes I am shocked into intense lasting pleasure (superior to even the best sex) by transcendent artistry. It is this that I seek as a listener. — magritte
The best song to have sex to
Pony by Ginuwine. It’s predictable: it’s the Magic Mike song. But I don’t play music when I have sex. I’ve been married for 25 years, we’re lucky if we do it. Maybe I should put it on.
"Four members of the band had taken on a fifth element." — 180 Proof
@180 Proof you have the best taste on here — Albero