Meanings can be learnt via inferences from observations on the real world and how others use the words in social situations. — Corvus
If that were so, no one would ever learn the meaning of a word.One cannot use words without knowing the meanings. — Corvus
Perhaps the point might have been expressed better. If someone says the cat is on the mat, there is a fact of the matter that we can check against - take a look and see. If someone says that cat ought be on the mat, there is no similar process available for us. We must instead decide.It's not all that odd. If someone tells you how things are, it is up to you to decide whether to believe them. — Ludwig V
That word. If everything hat applies to {1,2,3} applies to "...is red", then what more is there to "meaning"?...means... — J
Popper draws a clear distinction between the logic of falsifiability and its applied methodology. The logic of his theory is utterly simple: a universal statement is falsified by a single genuine counter-instance. Methodologically, however, the situation is complex: decisions about whether to accept an apparently falsifying observation as an actual falsification can be problematic, as observational bias and measurement error, for example, can yield results which are only apparently incompatible with the theory under scrutiny. — Popper, from SEP, (my bolding)
It's not just natural, it is inevitable. A part of the human condition is that we each decide what we do next, so in your words we must each "take on the role of God".My point is, one can always blame the God character and think how things should have gone, but in doing so one simply takes on the role of God. It's very natural to do this. — BitconnectCarlos
It's not between man and man. It's between man and God. — BitconnectCarlos
That's not what I recall. I will happily accept the essay you point to as a valid interpretation.After reading it, summarily reject all it says and tell me how horrified you are at the binding of Isaac. That's the process we've followed going on a couple of years here. — Hanover
I actually have it all figured out, understand the meaning of life and the nature of what exists, I'm just not telling anyone so you can all discover it for yourselves.
All we need is to trust God and no one gets hurt. — Fire Ologist
That was the sacrifice - not the act of a madman; not someone blindly obedient - it was a fully informed decision to, despite all else, trust God. — Fire Ologist
That argument might hold if there were agreement amongst the learned. There isn't.It can't be stated often enough that if perspicuity is rejected (which I do), then a 4 corners literalist interpretation is irrelevant — Hanover
And by this standard the stories of the Binding and of Job show culpability.Remember then: there is only one time that is important – now! It is the most important time because it is the only time when we have any power. The most necessary person is the one with whom you are, for no man knows whether he will ever have dealings with anyone else: and the most important affair is to do that person good, because for that purpose alone was man sent into this life.” — Tolstoy, The Three Questions
This is simply to renege on your responsibility to decide if an act is right or wrong, to hand that most central of judgements over to someone else. To look the other way.As humans our perspectives are limited and biased and to draw such broad and universal judgments such as which suffering is ultimately "justified" and which is "unjustified" is beyond us. The book stands against man's hubrism and his tendency of all encompassing judgment. — BitconnectCarlos


Replying her as this is off topic - fair enough. Present circumstances place the point in high relief. I've in mind something along the lines of John Rawls as modified by Martha Nussbaum, adopting a capabilities approach.I'm European. — ChatteringMonkey
A garage, by its very nature, tends toward disorder, for it is in its essence a space of storage and utility, where various objects accumulate over time. No matter how much one may strive to impose order upon it, the garage will inevitably revert to this state, as it is proper to its function. This tendency is not accidental but arises from its very purpose, much like how all things move toward their natural ends. — Aristotle
Cobbler's awls. No, I hope for a bit of conversation, some intelligent disagreement. I'm not insisting on agreement so much as enjoying disagreement.You insist that all align to your judgment. — BitconnectCarlos
Cool. So it's not that people make judgements that is problematic when you say"I have intuitions. I make judgments, for sure. — BitconnectCarlos
So your point remains obscure.I get it. You, like many others, have very strong intuitions about how things should be. — BitconnectCarlos
Kierkegaard saw something profound in it. You see nothing. — frank
You, like many others, — BitconnectCarlos
Someone's made a model of my desk...What do you make of this? — Hanover
I don't think nationalism is functionally all that different from religion. — ChatteringMonkey
Well religion is the institutionalisation of these values, how they get propagated in a given society, how and who can change them over time. — ChatteringMonkey
There's no argument here for that interpretation. You say religion is the believe in a set of common values, then in the next sentence replace "religion" with "faith".Faith then is the believe in a set of common values — ChatteringMonkey
Elon's fortune is of this ilk.ENRON CAPITALISM
You have two cows. You sell three of them to your public-listed company, using letters of credit opened by your brother-in-law at the bank, then execute a debt / equity swap with associated general offer so that you get all four cows back, with a tax deduction for keeping five cows. The milk rights of six cows are transferred via a Panamanian intermediary to a Cayman Islands company secretly owned by the majority shareholder, who sells the rights to all seven cows' milk back to the listed company. The annual report says that the company owns eight cows, with an option on one more.
Anyone who thinks abandoning your own reason is ever right or good, is a fool, or not a functioning person. Faith is not opposed to reason. — Fire Ologist
No, this behaviour is abominable, unjustifiable.They arrived at the place God had described to him. Abraham built an altar there and arranged the wood on it. He tied up his son Isaac and laid him on the altar on top of the wood. Then Abraham stretched out his hand and took the knife to kill his son as a sacrifice.
Madmen rationally justify their acts. What is described in Genesis 22 is madness.If a person performs some ritual, to praise God and bring blessings, they are using reason throughout, as necessary to complete any task successfully. — Fire Ologist
Indeed, bending over backwards to justify the unjustifiable. In the place of all those words, see a man preparing a fire, fettering his son and taking a knife to his throat. Judge that.Biblical interpretation is a field unto itself — Hanover
