To What Extent is the Idea of 'Liberty' Important For Us? "Too much rope" comes to mind. Someone wants to promote a previously unheard of view, say abortion or even right of the unborn, women's rights, modern transsexual surgery as "intrinsic human freedom", emancipation even, we'll assume in the pursuit of this "liberty for all" .. someone can, accurately, point out how it offers potential to be counter-productive to the very concept. Some will say abortion infringes upon the right of an unborn person, others say it infringes on the right of a woman's freedom to choose. Some say women's "rights", in a society of laws, rules, and equality already, not only diminishes gender equality but their own right of equal potential/progression in manifesting skills not possessed or refined, arbitrarily paying them more based on their gender and not their work value, simultaneously/counter-productively labeling them as inherently "lesser" and so needing to be paid more without acquiring more skills to truly become an equal, simply for being a different gender.
Why stop there though, it extends beyond rational belief, because liberty, that is to say the extremes, are not inherently rational. Say I want to engage in carnal relations with deceased animals, or why stop there how about people. How dare you and your fascistic authoritarianism even pretend like it can attempt to deny my pursuit of happiness simply because it's different than yours. Say I want to drive around schools at recess yelling obscenities and playing pornography at full blast. Again, how dare you attempt to become an enemy of the Constitution and human freedom in my presence... Etc, etc.