• European or Global Crisis?
    I think Vance wants to rally 'round the family. Musk wants to colonize Mars. Trump wants to avoid further prosecution while changing the name of the Gulf of Mexico. We'll see where it all lands.
  • European or Global Crisis?

    I don't think eating Europe is on the to-do list right now.
  • European or Global Crisis?

    If you can't beat 'em, join 'em?
  • What should the EU do when Trump wins the next election?
    This war is going to end.Hanover

    Russia has a tendency to want to annihilate the Ukrainian identity. It gives them joy to try. Ukrainians say no to this for some strange reason. I get the feeling this war might outlive all of us.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    More effective at what? Or do you care?tim wood

    Accomplishing their goals.
  • What is faith
    1) is faith an emotion or a thought? What if it is neitherGregory

    God almighty came down from heaven to save us from his own wrath by allowing himself to be tortured to death. This strategy worked, even though he didn't actually die and most people weren't saved. Faith is a bamboozle.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Intellectuals hate it when audacity is more effective than intelligence. :sad:
  • The News Discussion

    Do women make more doing the same jobs? Or do they just have better jobs?
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Is Vance actually the president at this point?
  • 'This Moment is Medieval'...

    He appointed the first female chief of staff. I think he is sexist, but wants to exploit talent more than he wants to misogynize.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    The National Guard is integrated into the Federal command structure. States have some authority toward mobilization but not an override of Executive decisions.Paine

    I hadn't realized that the SCOTUS' authority was backed by the executive branch. So the SCOTUS actually has no power over the executive. That means we were never too far from dictatorship. All it takes is an executive with the will to ignore the SCOTUS, and a legislative branch that's behind the executive. Voila.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    I take the view points, let them all rattle around in my head in a hurricane of different thoughts, not all are left standing.DifferentiatingEgg

    :up: More things for rattling:

    Kierkegaard said faith is like floating in water that is 70,000 fathoms deep. He was talking about faith that's along the lines of acceptance. On the other hand, I've never quite understood what Augustine was trying to do with faith. I wish I could ask him some questions. I don't think faith is really one concept for all uses of the word. You have to try to discern what someone means by it, put yourself in their shoes and see what they're seeing. But if they're experiences are very different from your own, you may be unable to grasp what they're seeing.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Second, the judicial system has (had?) great authority, but it doesn't have great power.BC

    So their power just came down to respect for rule of law? What about the National Guard?
  • The Musk Plutocracy

    If the goal is to pave the way for greater authoritarianism, the judicial branch would have to be rendered powerless. This occurred to me a while back, so I was expecting some ramp up in anti-judiciary rhetoric.

    In 1930's Louisiana, there was a governor who became a dictator by taking over the state legislature. He fired some judges and was eventually shot and killed by the son of one of the judges he fired. If history repeats, we should expect assassination attempts after judges are removed. The problem is that even if all the key players were killed, there's no viable opposition to take over right now. That doesn't mean it couldn't develop, but if it did, the US would sink into internal conflict in a way it hasn't experienced since the Civil War. I think most likely the US will be off the world stage for the foreseeable future.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    Seek God etc. [in your hearts] all else is talkENOAH

    "In the depths of our hearts the light of God is shining on a soundless sea with no shore.". --Rumi
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    You have to take something as granted, yes. That's a long way from what is involved in faith. One can review what one takes as granted, but to review what one takes on faith is to breech that faith.Banno

    Sounds like you made up your own religion.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    Or faith is the antithesis of rationality.Banno

    If you like. You were born with some of that irrational faith. You can't live without it.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    And, the average American manages a comfortable lifestyle on the average American income which is around $65,000 annually.
    https://www.sofi.com/learn/content/average-salary-in-us/
    Metaphysician Undercover

    Only 15.7% of Americans make that much. 57% of Americans make that or less. here

    Since you think $65,000 is enough to make ends meet without struggle for an average family, I'm guessing you're like a 100 years old?
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Even if that is representative of "the average American", how is it anything other than having to work for a living?Metaphysician Undercover

    Nobody was talking about working for a living. Ssu was saying America is rich because of its global influence. I was saying the average American isn't rich.
  • Ontology of Time
    Wouldn't it be wonderful to hear the sounds the workers made building the classical structures of Egypt?Banno

    That would be awesome
  • Ontology of Time

    Speaking of sliding, the delta blues beat comes from laboring songs, songs that are meant to coordinate action so everyone does the same thing at the same time. It creates anticipation. I wonder if laboring songs may have been part of the emergence of a sense of time. As ancient monument builders dragged giant stones, was the concept of a precise moment in the future coming into consciousness? When we all pull on the rope together?
  • What should the EU do when Trump wins the next election?


    Whoever's writing the software for this matrix is going off the rails.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump and Vance tell Zelensky to get out of the Oval Office. Get out!
  • The alt-right and race
    Sounds like an interesting read. Do you know of a free copy of the essay, or did you buy it? I’ll read it then comment.NOS4A2

    I couldn't find it on line. You can buy it from Amazon.com . It comes as a little paperback.
  • The alt-right and race
    The most obvious place where this plays out is with disorders like Down Syndrome, which are now screened for early in most pregnancies in some countries. People terminate these pregnancies at vastly higher rates, leading to very stark declines in prevalence in some countries (e.g. Iceland).Count Timothy von Icarus

    Downs isn't passed down genetically, though. It's a malfunction that takes place early during gestation. There wouldn't be any eugenics benefit from ending a Downs pregnancy.

    I understand the motivation behind eugenics, but I don't think we know enough to engage in it large scale. Knowing how genetic manipulation will effect a handful of people doesn't tell us anything about the wider implications for the whole population. Diseases sometimes come in pairs where having one condition gives immunity to some other. A broad eugenics program might show us the benefit behind some conditions that we now think of as noxious.

    Anyhow, the Alt-Right is fairly broad and in some sense the idea of "race realism" is more tangential than I think a lot of coverage suggests.Count Timothy von Icarus

    Nick Land's sentiments are central to the contemporary alt-right and the opening lines of Dark Enlightenment are about race. That's why I brought it up. I wasn't looking for low hanging fruit. That would be disingenuous.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Does "struggles" mean that they have to go to work five days a week?Metaphysician Undercover

    Living paycheck to paycheck is pretty common.

    Worrying is self-inflicted anxiety.Metaphysician Undercover

    It often comes from a heroin deficiency.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Now Trump is doing exactly the same, but even higher tariffs when the World is far more integrated than it was in the 1930'sssu

    I think I was the one who told you that a trade war precipitated the Great Depression. Now you're teaching it back to me.

    We can go over the reasons why Russian imperialism and military aggression is bad for Europe, but now the question is just why to start appeasing those, who see the US as it's enemy and alienate those, who thought being your allies?ssu

    Basically because the US can destroy Russia without Europe's help. If the US needed European support, it would be a different story.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    And do you think that starting a trade war, which likely ends up in a global downturn, will help that?ssu

    It has the potential to. A trade war would help American labor as long as it doesn't coincide with a panic that crashes the system.

    You don't want to have a welfare state, you don't want universal health care or free education. You could easily have that, but you do not want it. You want to give tax breaks to the rich and believe that the best thing is not only to man the highest positions in the administration with billionaires, but to give unchecked power to the richest man in the World. That's the United States Americans seem to want and vote for. Because obviously, for some reason you buy the argument that is this rule by the rich or then everything else is Venezuela type socialism.

    It's all that you are doing yourself by your own choosing. And loosing that leadership role won't make it anymore easier. Actually it's the American defense companies that will be hurt when Europe starts focusing on it's own military industry.

    In fact, you can both have a strong military and a welfare state and people be prosperous. But that means that the rich do have to pay taxes. Sweden during the Cold War is actually a great example of this: a rather small country could have it's own military industrial complex capable of building top of the line fighters, submarines and even building an own nuclear weapon. And also creating that welfare state.

    The thing that either it's guns or butter is the wrong idea.
    ssu

    I'm not sure why you're having this reaction. Are you afraid Russia is going to invade your country and Europe will just stand by and let it happen?
  • The alt-right and race
    Yeah, I don't think that's a left problem though. I think we're seeing that from all quarters. The left and right are just doing that in different ways.flannel jesus

    Agreed.
  • The alt-right and race
    zombie? Not sure what exactly is meant by thatflannel jesus

    No reflection. Just outrage.
  • The alt-right and race
    Hayek favored dictatorship as the best way to preserve the freedom of the market. He's an ideological grandfather of Land and his friends.
    — frank

    On what basis do you say that?
    Paine

    I read a book about him? He praised the Chilean dictator and commented that a dictator is the best solution to threats to freedom. I'm not going to look it up and provide a quote though. I just don't care enough. Sorry.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    You do know that Russia has more nuclear weapons than the US has, btw.ssu

    Ok.

    It really comes down to this: when you cannot understand how much of the current prosperity you have is thanks to the Superpower status, it's really the epic failure of your own government to make it's case for this. Other countries have happily given the US the leadership role. But once other countries don't listen to you, you will understand it.ssu

    The average American struggles to make ends meet. They worry about how they're going to afford to retire. The ones just below average show up to the emergency room to get healthcare and when they're told that they need to stop working to get over their pneumonia, they start crying and explaining that they're working two jobs and they have to take care of their kids and they can't take any time off.

    That is America. Thanks for the leadership role.
  • The alt-right and race
    As a lefty, I largely agree with this and I've been saying similar things for years. The left shoots themselves in the foot by becoming extreme caricatures of themselves.flannel jesus

    I also get what he's saying. There's a little bit of zombie-ness in progressivism.
  • The alt-right and race
    Take Hayek, for instance, who advocated for a completely free market but did not support the deletion of civic governance.Paine

    Hayek favored dictatorship as the best way to preserve the freedom of the market. He's an ideological grandfather of Land and his friends.

    What Land describes as 'conservative'Paine

    What did he describe as conservative? He isn't conservative in any meaningful sense. He's post-Leftism.
  • The alt-right and race
    By that measure, the alt-right does not want to have control of the commons but to force everybody else to live in their ghetto.Paine

    Libertarians truly want freedom and they think democracy has failed in its mission to provide that. They have joined hands with Neo-Nazis in order to make their sentiments known. To what extent do they realize that there's a looming disaster in that? I honestly don't think they care. They're useless dust for history's bin.
  • The alt-right and race
    Would it be a bad thing is the liberal world order ended Frank?ChatteringMonkey

    If you mean should America's global influence end. Yes. It should.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    So, St. Thomas's Five Ways demonstrate a lack of faith and are contrary to Church doctrine?Count Timothy von Icarus

    If he required any of that for belief, yes, it would show a lack of faith.

    I'll tell you a secret about mysticism. As soon as you stop trying to be right, you'll feel God's presence. It's pretty cool.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    Apparently, you know more about how to instruct Christians on their own faith than St. Anselm.Count Timothy von Icarus

    St Anselm was very well aware that faith is not based on reason.
  • Logical Arguments for God Show a Lack of Faith; An Actual Factual Categorical Syllogism
    Au contraire, the argument has two premises inconsistent with doctrine (see the Catechism aboveCount Timothy von Icarus

    You've got to be kidding me. He's clearly saying that if you require argumentation for belief in God, you lack faith.

    The Pauline doctrine and the official Church teaching is that faith is a gift of God. It is not obtained through reason.

    Read what he wrote. His view is traditional.