The Philosophy Forum

  • Forum
  • Members
  • HELP

  • Ukraine Crisis
    ↪Tzeentch
    , the UK stopped being a global (colonial) power, the US retreated from Vietnam, the USSR pulled out of Afghanistan, ... I'm sure there have been bruised egos. Should Ukraine be intact sometime in the foreseeable future, Russia will continue on without, perhaps even a bit improved, maybe along the lines of what
    ↪Olivier5
    suggested. Hardly impossible or unheard of.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Some parallel developments, FYI

    Council adopts decision not to accept Russian documents issued in Ukraine and Georgia
    — European Council · Dec 8, 2022

    The Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Karim A.A. Khan KC, announces conclusion of the investigation phase in the Situation in Georgia
    — Karim Ahmad Khan · International Criminal Court · Dec 16, 2022

    • Russo-Georgian War (Wikipedia)
    • Responsibility for the Russo-Georgian War (Wikipedia)


    A couple of scattered, peripherally related news items ...

    Russia sends St. Petersburg riot police to Mariupol to stop new protests
    — Daniel Stewart · News 360 · Dec 16, 2022

    Someone, quick, the coast is clear, incite some bigtime protests in St Petersburg. :up: :grin:

    Israeli-tied Moldovan TV channels halt Russia-Ukraine war reporting
    — Reuters via The Jerusalem Post · Dec 17, 2022

    Ilan Shor, "the young one", is done with corruption/subversion in Moldova I guess.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Russia rejects Zelenskiy call for troop pullout, saying Ukraine must accept 'realities'
    — Mark Trevelyan, Guy Faulconbridge · Reuters · Dec 13, 2022
    The Ukrainian side needs to take into account the realities that have developed during this time. And these realities indicate that new subjects have appeared in the Russian Federation. They appeared as a result of referendums that took place in these territories. Without taking these new realities into account, no kind of progress is possible. — Peskov

    The sham annexations may have to break, one way or other.
    If that causes collisions in Moscow, then so be it; if they don't break, then so be it as well.
    I guess it's illegal to criticize in Russia; they can break, however. (2014, 2022)
  • If you were (a) God for a day, what would you do?
    Isn't that one of those unanswerable questions? If by "God" is meant "know-it-all" and such? :) Until omniscient, it's not really possible to answer.

    Other than that (2m:22s)...

  • Ukraine Crisis
    :D

    Ukrainian man reunited with his rabbit after Russia destroyed his house
    — Josh Milton · Metro News · Dec 14, 2022

    Gave me a chuckle
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Putin says Russia may be fighting in Ukraine for a long time
    — Mark Trevelyan · Reuters · Dec 7, 2022
    They consider Russia a second-class country that has no right to exist. This is the whole problem, the whole trouble. — Putin

    ↪boethius
    , I guess I could repeat, though the thread is rife with repeats already. It so happens that some of the bolder Kremlin'ers say that Washington set up a coup and installed a Nazi junta in Kyiv, other of those folk say Russia need to liberate Ukraine from a Nazi regime. Sure, it's propaganda (good point :up: :wink:), because it's false, yet there you have their justification, what government officials and TV broadcast. (Already posted whatever sources, quotes, speeches, commentaries, propaganda, situation reports on the ground, comparisons, whatever.) The implication is that their supposed justification was a ruse, an excuse, plus there are additional reasons for this implication, outside of their propaganda — as (also) mentioned, you may inspect their actions. Hence the point, a ruse, an excuse. On the other hand, if you wish to justify what the Kremlin'ers claim, then you'll have to show the supposed Ukrainian Nazi regime (from memory, you ignored/declined that prior), that it's not propaganda after all. While rounding up what characterizes Nazi rule, I noticed some indicators that...nevermind, you'll just designate it all propaganda (again). :D

    Zelenskiy shuts court, says Ukraine can fight graft, Russia at same time
    — Dan Peleschuk · Reuters · Dec 13, 2022
    This story has drawn to a close. But the story of reforms continues – it continues, even in the time of such a war. — Zelenskyy
    Ukraine's parliament enacts reform laws recommended by EU - Speaker
    — The Jerusalem Post · Dec 14, 2022

    Such likes ↑ at least, look positive.

    While reading ...

    Exclusive: The global supply trail that leads to Russia’s killer drones (via MSN)
    — Stephen Grey, Maurice Tamman, Maria Zholobova · Reuters · Dec 15, 2022

    I was vaguely reminded of ...

    Stop funding Russia’s nuclear weapons
    — Henry Sokolski; The Hill; Nov 13, 2022
    — Nov 14, 2022

    Florida, Hong Kong, in addition to US/EU funds going to Rosatom, ..., the plot thickens.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    ↪boethius
    , if you think something's off then hit the report button/link. It's a small flag at the bottom of posts (hover → •••).

    It's about the Ukraine crisis, not just your own take, though that's cool too, despite the occasional curious tunnel vision.
    Some reports might suggest getting the diplomats scrambling immediately, others suggest some un/predictability factor of the Kremlin, other reports still may suggest whatever other things. Without data, there isn't anything to chat (or reason) about.
    You keep ignoring that Putin, Pavlov, Solovyov, Patrushev, Medvedev, Chernyshov, with Peskov, Matviyenko, and others in tow, speak of liberating Ukraine from a Nazi regime (previous posts, all over actually) — a ruse, an excuse — fail. For that matter, it's pretty clear that Kremlin has no particular concern for the Ukrainians (also prior posts).
    Anyway, I suppose we could designate it all propaganda, though government officials and public TV characters are influential enough, more so with the oppression in place and enforced.

    I am happy you agree that Nazi's are indeed a problem — boethius

    I'm glad too. Have you seen (indications of) Nazism here...? Fascism racism ... for that matter? Anyone belonging in Tzeentch's fiery pit?

    We could also keep one line of the chit-chat purely on the military tactics, which would exclude speculation about ulterior motives and such.

    Medvedev of the Russian Security Council:

    Pseudo-Ukrainian rabid mongrels with Russian surnames, choking on their toxic saliva, declare that their enemy is located within the borders of Russia, from the West to Vladivostok. Rabies has no cure.
    It is much more difficult for us - our enemy has dug in not only in the Kyiv province of our native Little Russia. It's in Europe, North America, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and a whole host of other contemporary Nazi-sworn places.
    Therefore, we are increasing the production of the most powerful means of destruction. Including those based on new principles.
    — Dmitry Medvedev · Dec 11, 2022
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Impressive

    Photographers Kostyantyn Liberov and Vlada Liberova published a photo of the "graveyard" of shells that Russia fired at Kharkiv this year.
    — Reserve Petty Officer · Dec 4, 2022

  • Ukraine Crisis
    Inside Bakhmut: The strange and senseless death trap draining Ukraine's tired army
    — Justin Yau, Ben Farmer · The Telegraph · Dec 9, 2022

    More or less Prigozhin's and Kadyrov's free playground ...

    wave of assaults carried out by Russian mercenaries and poorly-equipped reservists

    Grotesque.

    I'd suggest footage be broadcast all over Russia, well all over really, without propagandist editing that is.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    EDITORIAL: The high cost of peace at any price
    — Toronto Sun · Dec 9, 2022

    The editorial doesn't really make a whole lot of points, just the usual (which is not a dismissal of them).
    Allowing the invaders to get away with it is too close to being complicit.
    They'll learn from success, others (autocrats, despots, tyrants, dictators, whatever) will take note, and thus we may end up putting it off to our children (or their children).
    It's not new and not that hard to understand; we ought to learn from history.
    (Plato Tacitus Burke Mill Niemöller Wiesel)
    But, in this case, it's for the Ukrainians to decide, their homes (whatever is left of them), their self-governance, are on the line.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    By Covid? — Tzeentch

    By "The fiery pit" (and whatever else you have in store for people).
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Lies and Vladimir Putin's political culture: "Intelligence Matters"
    — Michael Morell, Andrew Weiss, Paulina Smolinski · CBS News · Dec 7, 2022

    Well, the (sociopathic) opportunism über alles is something Putin shares with der Führer.

    Russia's Putin Vows More Strikes On Ukraine Energy Infrastructure
    — Via NDTV · Dec 8, 2022

    I guess the Ukrainians aren't really allowed to try throwing the invaders out? Such goes Putin's rhetorical move. Not the best excuse. Destruction continues.

    Slovakia compares negotiating peace with Russia to the dialogues with Hitler that led to WWII
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Dec 8, 2022

    ↪Tzeentch
    , Macron is "Absolute scum", belonging in "The fiery pit"? :D I guess, by your take, humans best go extinct, or at least be markedly decimated. Not quite a realistic outlook. Or maybe just another hyperbole.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    He threatened the people of France for exercising their human right to bodily autonomy. "Dictator" is being kind. Absolute scum of the Earth, better? The fiery pit is too good for that man. — Tzeentch

    Surely you jest.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Volodymyr Zelensky named TIME's Person of the Year 2022

    2022 was year the horror of war returned to Europe (minor warning: graphic)
    — Jill Lawless · AP News · Dec 8, 2022
  • Climate change denial
    ↪Mikie
    , bit trigger happy there?
    I'd question McKitrick's take on the matter, hence asking.
  • Climate change denial
    Not quite sure what to make of this...

    Opinion: The Parliamentary Budget Officer just debunked climate alarmism
    — Ross McKitrick · Financial Post · Dec 7, 2022

    Either way...
    Don't panic :up:
    Get your (our) act together :up:
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Ukraine war shows Europe too reliant on U.S., Finland PM says (via Yahoo)
    — Essi Lehto, Terje Solsvik, Nick Macfie · Reuters · Dec 2, 2022

    Finland’s prime minister acknowledges that «Europe is not strong enough».
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Dec 2, 2022

    Well, there you have it.

    The EU is riddled with babbling bureaucracy thumb-twiddling impotence sitting-on-hands — not going to cut it. For that matter, there's a fair amount of EU dislike within the EU already. The EU isn't about defense anyway.

    A Russian autocrat isn't going to pay much attention to that, but surely might try to fuel it. And facing an individual European country won't faze them much either. Despots may just grab what they want, and roll over what they don't.

    A cohesive European defense, on the other hand, preferably including the UK and Ukraine :wink:, might do it. The resources exist, at least.

    Until then, NATO it is. And NATO, apparently, scares Putin.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    ↪Tzeentch
    , others have suggested that it goes both ways.

    :up: Address the point they brought up (plus public awareness) — Dec 3, 2022

    Macron’s idea of ‘security guarantees’ to Russia faces backlash
    — Alexandra Brzozowski · EURACTIV · Dec 5, 2022

    French president Macron criticized for suggesting ’security guarantees’ for Russia
    — Reuters via Al Arabiya · Dec 5, 2022

    Anyway, opening some talks would be :up:
  • Ukraine Crisis
    State TV, Russia:

    Putin Cronies Resort to Begging on Live TV Over War Failures
    — Julia Davis · The Daily Beast · Dec 4, 2022
    I am amazed by our people—and I unfortunately know many of them—including those in very high circles, who are afraid of this and are scared to call things by their proper names because of what people over there may think. We could spit on what they think over there! People who are afraid of the Hague—listen, you should be afraid to lose, to be humiliated and be afraid to betray your people. Let me tell you that if we manage to lose, the Hague—whether real or hypothetical—will come even for a street cleaner who is sweeping the cobblestones behind the Kremlin. — Simonyan
    There won’t be any Hague if this happens, there won’t be anything at all. The whole world will be reduced to ashes. — Solovyov
    God forbid, we can’t allow it and don’t even say it out loud but suppose that suddenly something happens and our country is unable to achieve victory: then we should proceed from the premise that everyone with no exception will be held accountable—whether they are located within the Russian Federation or abroad. Those abroad will most likely be immediately arrested. Whether he is a collaborator of Putin’s regime or was just passing by, it doesn’t matter. All of us will be considered guilty. What’s at stake is not only the existence of the country, but also the carefree existence of every citizen of the Russian Federation—our future is on the line. In order to avoid the Hague tribunals, the initiation of criminal cases, compensation, reparations—in order to avoid all this, we need a total intensification of military actions, we have to squeeze and pressure them so much that they approach us about a truce or a peace process… Otherwise, they will insist on capitulation. — Skabeyeva
    How can we sleep while knowing that we aren’t sharing and aren’t participating? Rich people should get a hold of themselves and remember that we can’t continue living the way we’ve been living since the disintegration of the Soviet Union. We have to restore social equality. I am calling on you, citizens: you have to share! Raise the taxes on the rich and the well-to-do people. What is there to be afraid of? Raise the taxes! — Simonyan

    Good grief. Promoting paranoia to the masses? It's Ukraine that's on fire. Muscovite street cleaners aren't in the line of fire.

    Larger Wheat Harvest in Ukraine Than Expected
    — NASA · Dec 4, 2022
    However, Russia will likely reap the benefit of a significant portion of the close to 27-million-ton wheat crop, said Skakun. The analysis showed that 5.8 million tons of wheat was harvested from areas that were not under Ukrainian control. That represents a loss of at least $1 billion, Abbassian noted.

    Looting, after a fashion?

    Rebuilding Ukraine After Russian Invasion Will Cost $500-600 Billion, Says World Bank VP
    — RFE/RL · Dec 4, 2022

    Costly.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Putin takes war to new level of 'barbarism,' U.S. diplomat says
    — Tom Balmforth · Reuters · Dec 3, 2022

    Diplomacy is obviously everyone's objective but you have to have a willing partner. And it's very clear, whether it's the energy attacks, whether it's the rhetoric out of the Kremlin and the general attitude, that Putin is not sincere or ready for that. Putin has taken this war to a new level of barbarism, taking it into every single Ukrainian home as he tries to turn off the lights and the water and achieve what he couldn't on the battlefield. — Nuland
    It is not for Nuland to teach the world - only the United States and NATO combined destroyed more energy networks than the United States destroyed by itself. — Zakharova

    But...then that's an admission...? :o Bad rhetorical tactic, ma'am.
    (two wrongs don't make a right, whataboutism, diversion)

    Notice how neatly this replays a particular narrative (while ignoring a few things of relevance) — with evil NATO, Nazis, etc, rousing anger — dancing (and yelling) to the tune of a particular dish of propaganda:

    The USA Caused the War in Ukraine, and Only the USA Can End It
    — Bryan Davies · CODEPINK · Nov 24, 2022

    Some have (and perhaps will) lap such colorific bias up without further ado. It's not that it's all plain wrong, more that it ignores too much, skips past a few things of relevance, expresses too much preconception, ending up with a story of wholesale blame-switchery. Had that "PINK TANK ~ BLOG" been posted a good while back, then it could perhaps have been said to provide a perspective surely worthwhile of consideration, but not any longer. At least they got one thing more or less right, in principle (if only Putin + team had taken that to heart):

    NO WAR

    Anyone can sympathize. And then get their feet back on the ground.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Macron says new security architecture should give guarantees for Russia
    — Geert De Clercq, William Maclean · Reuters · Dec 3, 2022

    This means that one of the essential points we must address - as President Putin has always said - is the fear that NATO comes right up to its doors, and the deployment of weapons that could threaten Russia. That topic will be part of the topics for peace, so we need to prepare what we are ready to do, how we protect our allies and member states, and how to give guarantees to Russia the day it returns to the negotiating table. — Macron

    :up: Address the point they brought up (plus public awareness)
  • Ukraine Crisis
    (
    ↪Paine
    , I didn't really mean to argue, more like add some stuff :up:)
  • Ukraine Crisis
    ↪Tzeentch
    , using nuclear weapons would be bad for Russia as well as for others. Unless you think Putin doesn't care? The doctrine (if you want to call it that), is the mutually assured destruction thing. That's not quite the case here. No one has threatened with marching on Moscow ‡, let alone spraying nukes over Russia. It's the other way around, Putin's Russia has proven a real, present threat to Ukraine. Even if Putin ordered the (tactical) nukes in, I wouldn't expect a straight escalation to world war. NATO and others are more tempered than so. But Russia would definitely get attention, eyes-on, not in a positive way. This has been suggested both by Washington and Beijing, albeit in the usual political fashion.

    ↪Paine
    , it's just that those formal annexations have become but a ritual, a performance to appease certain sensibilities. :/ Fake, a sham, an imposition. Just about everyone already knows, but that might not work on some mindsets, and hence the humbug sticks around.

    When it comes to talks, which I'd think generally is seen as a positive thing, it seems that various parties say they're ready, serious, good to go, just say the word — except, only if what they bring to the table is already accepted. And so, no talks. Wouldn't be talks anyway, would be declarations.

    As an aside, per se I'm not quite convinced that Crimea is as secured (Russian) as some. I guess it depends on Ukrainian support and such. Also, rumors on the street will have it that bomb shelters are being prepared in Moscow, despite no indication they'd have to be used. I suppose, if they want to waste resources (instead of using them for their "Ukraine project")...?

    ‡ Except Danilov perhaps, depending? Some have argued for political change, like doing away with the oppression, autocracy, shamming, rigging, but that's not the same.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    ↪SophistiCat


    These are our people — Putin

    Except for the "Nazis" and those that don't want to be subjects... :D (the evil uncle that nieces and nephews stay away from comes to mind)

    Putin Ally Blames Crisis on Rise of Black U.S. Music Stars He Calls ‘Descendants of African American Slaves’
    — Allison Quinn · The Daily Beast · Dec 1, 2022
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Oleksiy Danilov opines:

    Ukraine calls for «destruction» of Russia to prevent it from pursuing its colonial aims
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Dec 1, 2022

    Not really helping. (Regardless of how in/accurate it is.) It'll just give reason to fear, and fuel the zealots. The fact remains that Putin's Russia invaded, is waging war, destroying, etc.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Hypothesis (just to write it out explicitly):

    Putin + team want Crimea, at least. A secured Donbas would sort of help with connecting Russia and Crimea (Kerch is a bit skimpy). All of Ukraine would be :up:, and would connect Russia and Transnistria. Farms, resources, ..., go beyond geo/military gain. Stated/official reasons, rhetoric, various efforts, propaganda, etc, are means to that end.

    Kyiv wants the invaders to leave and not come back. That includes the interference/insurgence in Donbas. (And quit the destruction.)

    ↑ consistent with observations, not overly complex/speculative, plausible
  • Ukraine Crisis
    NATO renews membership vow to Ukraine, pledges arms and aid
    — Stephen McGrath, Lorne Cook, Ellen Knickmeyer · AP News · Nov 29, 2022
    NATO's door is open. Russia does not have a veto. — Stoltenberg
    If, as Stoltenberg hinted, NATO supplies the Kyiv fanatics with Patriot complexes along with NATO personnel, they will immediately become a legitimate target of our armed forces. I hope the Atlantic impotents understand this. — Medvedev

    Zelenskiy Invites Musk to Visit Ukraine in Response to His Talk of Peace Deal
    — Daniel Flatley · Bloomberg · Nov 30, 2022

    Putin + team requires/demands (Nov 11, 2022) ≈

    • legal guarantees that Ukraine will never join NATO, signed ✓ and set in stone in Ukraine's constitution
    • that Ukraine (the world?) recognize independence of Donetsk + Luhansk
    • that Ukraine (the world?) recognize Crimea as part of Russia
    • (Ukrainian surrender, demilitarization, deNazification has been mentioned a few times)
    • (Moscow is not to be attacked :grin:)


    The former could likely be worked out without that much difficulty if Russia was to give a similar guarantee to leave Ukraine alone, what NATO membership would help with in the first place. The two latter more or less constitute a non-licet land grab (besides, Donetsk + Luhansk wouldn't be independent but more or less under Moscow control, a signature move of theirs).

    Kyiv requires/demands (Nov 23, 2022) ≈

    • apart from neutrality / some sort of UN oversight perhaps, Ukraine otherwise intact, free, sovereign, self-governing
    • Russian military personnel in Ukraine to go home, and no Russian insurgency or other interference
    • Ukrainians taken to Russia to be recorded and (allowed) to return home, first and foremost children and prisoners
    • guarantees to be signed ✓ for all to see
    • (compensation for destruction or similar has come up)


    Other items that have come up ≈

    • investigation into war crimes, prosecution of war criminals
    • (has Kherson + Zaporizhia been added to Donetsk + Luhansk?)


    Some requirements/demands are incompatible. Others could be pursued now. As far as I can tell, all of the items would have to be brought to the table, whether they'll be rejected, considered, approved or not. Otherwise it's not really genuine.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    National state TV, Russia

    Here is what one man wrote [to] me, someone by the name of Victor Rozumovsky: “Maybe it’s time to stop presenting lies as the truth. Stop deceiving people. Rational thinking people no longer believe any of this.” You know what Victor? If you are in Russia, we are going to find you. We will find out everything about you. You won’t know a moment’s peace. — Vladimir Solovyov

    :D

  • Ukraine Crisis
    Zelenska (visiting the UK), von der Leyen (fronting the EU), and UN are on the same page regarding war crimes ...

    Zelensky’s wife given standing ovation by MPs while urging UK to be ‘leader’
    — Liam Coleman · Metro News · Nov 29, 2022

    EU seeks tribunal to probe possible Russian war crimes in Ukraine
    — Bart Meijer, Andrew Heavens · Reuters · Nov 30, 2022

    It's more doubtful what they can effectively do, though.
    What could they do?
    (Limit Putin's vacation spots some?)
  • Ukraine Crisis
    You got me, I'm a Kremlin propagandist. :rofl: — Tzeentch

    Not what I meant. Look at the quotes'n'comments again.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    vassals — Tzeentch
    even greater sacrifice of autonomy — Tzeentch
    lapdog — Tzeentch
    overlordship — Tzeentch
    overlordship — Tzeentch

    ↑ this is propaganda'ish'esque, hyperbolic spin (on one page alone, like on a mission)

    But that's fine, just have to take the verbiage for what it is.

    The true anarchist is always outnumbered.
    Will it be by organized thugs or a democratic majority?
    — Nov 19, 2022

    I guess wants are of some relevance.

    Think for a while about it. — ssu

    :up:
  • Ukraine Crisis
    More countries are moving towards authoritarianism - report
    — Héloise Urvoy · Euronews · Nov 30, 2022
    International democracies are weakening as authoritarianisms deepen their shortcomings.
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Nov 30, 2022
    Global State of Democracy Report 2022: Forging Social Contracts in a Time of Discontent
    — The International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (IDEA)

    I'll take the tedious task of ruling with an iron fist.
    Just need some compensation, like a new PC, a new furnace.
    And enough of this crap already:

    Russia says it will focus on building nuclear arms infrastructure in 2023
    — Reuters · Nov 30, 2022

    ugalexao5nemfhb8.jpg
    ↑ Source: Democracy Tracker

    ↪Olivier5 It doesn't really matter, since if the new status quo doesn't in some way satisfy the Russians, it's going to lead to war again sooner or later. — Tzeentch

    If we're talking Stalinesque borders + control from Moscow, then it's looking grim.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Short footage from the ground ...

    Kherson residents evacuate while those who stay struggle to survive
    — Matthew Chance · CNN · Nov 29, 2022 · 2m:57s



    Bring in the NASAMS and such. :up:
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Heusgen: 'Russia is playing games all over the place'
    — Sabina Fati · DW · Nov 29, 2022

    The Romanian president is right. Over the last years, NATO hasn't concentrated enough on the Black Sea. We had all our eyes on the Baltic Sea, where we also see Russian aggression, but the Russian war against Ukraine has now put the Black Sea in the center of our attention. Yes, we have to be much more active in the region, but I think that it's a signal that we're having the NATO Foreign Ministers' Meeting in Bucharest, also the Munich Security Conference is hosting the Munich Leaders Meeting here for the first time. I think that the president's wish to draw more attention to the region is actually now being heard by partners. — Christoph Heusgen
    They are trying to blackmail, they are trying to regain Moldova in its sphere of influence and that's why we have to support Moldova by all means, but particularly now, by economic means. — Christoph Heusgen

    I guess the Black Sea and Moldova might get more eyes-on.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Exclusive: India asked by sanctions-hit Russia for parts for key sectors
    — Aditi Shah, Aftab Ahmed. Gleb Stolyarov · Reuters · Nov 29, 2022

    The sanctions are apparently having some effect.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Putin’s decree on constitutional amendments to complete accession process for new regions
    — TASS · Oct 4, 2022

    Putin calls for integrating the four annexed Ukrainian regions into the Russian judicial system
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Nov 29, 2022

    Land grab. Veiled in rhetoric, masked by misdirection.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    Though to be expected I guess, I'd find the re-culturation/indoctrination attempts a bit ... embarrassing when exposed.

    Russia is here forever. There should be no doubt about this. There will be no return to the past. — Andrey Turchak (May 2022)

    In this video from a liberated town in #Kharkiv region, east #Ukraine, Ukrainian soldiers removed a Russian propaganda poster saying “We are one people with Russia”. Only to reveal a poster with national poet Shevchenko’s verse “Fight and you will win”. — Alex Kokcharov (Sep 10, 2022)

    Kherson removes pro-Russia signs, puts up pro-Ukrainian ones (via US News)
    — Reuters · Nov 22, 2022

    Oleksandr Tkachenko: 'The civilized world must take active measures to prevent the Russian propaganda machine from winning'
    — Oleksandr Tkachenko · Le Monde · Nov 24, 2022

    AP PHOTOS: Propaganda billboards embodied Russian occupation
    — Bernat Armangue · The Independent · Dec 2, 2022

    I have no objection to the modern nation state. I think it's an excellent, pragmatic way to organise governance. I object to the ludicrous notion that it has some moral value. It has none. If moving a border saves lives, move the border. Hell, if moving a border makes the trains run better, move the border. It's a nothing, a trivial bit of bureaucracy. It's absolute insanity to reify it to something worth dying in the thousands for. — Isaac

    Not quite "the modern nation state". Maybe some day?

    ↪Tzeentch
    , not a defense/military club, though. With NATO around, that would be a bit odd (or redundant to some extent) I guess.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    It is likely the United States orchestrated the sabotage of Nord Stream — Tzeentch

    As a matter of financial gain? (Russia and the UK blame each other)


    Anyway, does this seem dis/agreeable to anyone?

    • most want the invaders to leave, and to bring about a situation where the displaced can head on home, reunite with family/friends, ...
    • most want to show that such land grab attempts won't go unnoticed/uncontested/unchallenged, and that such re-culturation attempts are disgusting/criminal, the less feasible the better
    • most want to bring this stuff out to people as well, for all to see, show other ways
    • few (but maybe some) want more haters, destruction, world war, autocrats, autocrats with nuclear weapons, oppression, ...
    • (... and other things, please correct)

    Whatever is un/wanted taken together (which complicates things) would then reflect in actions taken, yes?
  • Ukraine Crisis
    The Five Conspiracy Theories That Putin Has Weaponized
    — Ilya Yablokov · The New York Times · Apr 25, 2022

    ‘Weaponisation of everything’: Putin’s hybrid warfare exposed by hidden attacks on Europe
    — Tara Fair · Express · Nov 28, 2022

    ↑ Material for a Bond movie? (hmm Putin could use a scar or something)

    According to Zakharova, it's like Russia against the world:

    Russia denounces Pope Francis’ latest words as proof of his «Russophobia».
    — Daniel Stewart · News360 · Nov 28, 2022

    Ironically perhaps, their efforts might turn that into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
  • Ukraine Crisis
    interesting to keep an eye on, since not only Russia is reluctant to return the occupied Kuril Islands to Japan but it also started militarizing them: https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/why-are-russia-and-japan-gridlocked-on-the-question-of-the-kuril-islands-58074 — neomac

    Not their only move either

    • The (melting) Arctic? Aug 25, 2022 and some more recent moves
    • Africa? Nov 16, 2022 (perhaps a bit on the clandestine side)

    NATO allies wake up to Russian supremacy in the Arctic (via Yahoo)
    — Jacob Grønholt-Pedersen, Gwladys Fouche · Reuters · Nov 16, 2022
    Putin touts Russia's 'Arctic power' with launch of nuclear icebreakers (via CTV News, The Telegraph)
    — Reuters · Nov 22, 2022
    Russian military back to harassing the Canadian Arctic
    — Tristin Hopper · National Post · Nov 25, 2022
Home » jorndoe
More Comments

jorndoe

Start FollowingSend a Message
  • About
  • Comments
  • Discussions
  • Uploads
  • Other sites we like
  • Social media
  • Terms of Service
  • Sign In
  • Created with PlushForums
  • © 2025 The Philosophy Forum