But you have to understand that I never saw my 2nd amendment right being taken away the first time. — ArguingWAristotleTiff
Why? — Baden
I would trust you with a gun — Baden
I asked you why it's not an infringement to ban machine guns and bazookas etc. — Baden
It is because it makes it an unfair fight with anyone, law or lawless. — ArguingWAristotleTiff
How is it unfair if both sides have the same weapon? E.g. a machine gun or bazooka? — Baden
So what's your answer if not that? — Baden
Just answer the question, please. Is it an infringment on your 2nd amendment right that you can't? — Baden
(If it's just because they are illegal then we can just make any gun we want illegal and voilà, no infringement.) — Baden
So, you are changing your answer now and think Americans have the right to bear bazookas? — Baden
Do Americans have the right to bear bazookas or not? Please just answer the question. It's a yes or no. And why is it more absurd than asking if they have the right to bear any other kind of weapon? — Baden
Ok, now you've changed your mind again. A moment ago you said it would infringe their rights if their bazookas were taken away. Can you just pick one position and stick to it, please. — Baden
Now, you are saying it's legality that matters. So, if assault weapons are illegal in illinois now, then it's not a 2nd amendment infringement just as with bazookas being illegal it's not a 2nd amendment infringement. — Baden
So, every weapon that has ever been legal is protected under the 2nd amendment? And every weapon that has never been legal is not protected? That's your position?? — Baden
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.