Comments

  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    Does it relate to the desire for consciousness?Vera Mont

    Is it even possible to have desires without consciousness?
  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    The badly attached 10" I-beams are always in the ceiling.Vera Mont

    They would not be able to fall on the people if they were in the floor, and that would not be tension building as they wait to be rescued. Sci-Fi is still fiction even if the authors have made it as realistic as possible, it has to be exciting to sell.
  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    Not quite following what would bend a convex support arch, but okay.Vera Mont

    High pressure or vacuum are terrible forces, they can bend or pull apart almost anything if it is not strong enough.
    If you look at this image you will see that they try to keep the internal support beams straight as much as possible. On submarines and I would suppose star-ships the beams would be specially made in the form of the hull but they would not use curved beams for internal support.

    00shipbuilding3-videoSixteenByNine3000-v2.jpg?year=2020&h=1688&w=3000&s=e05698637a3573c5f56113bb8205caeaea22608e356d33f1b42a62ac7a7fa4e8&k=ZQJBKqZ0VN&tw=1
  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    Why do curved spaceships have so many straight steel beams in the ceiling and why do the beams fall down so easily?Vera Mont

    Same reason as ships and planes, for structural force. Curved beams are used to hold the outer plating but it is not a good idea to have curved support beams inside, the bend too easily.

    As to why the fall, it would not be exciting if everything stayed in place would it? The same as sparks flying out of electrical equipment and in the next scene everything is normal and working.
  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    Not really. They never tell you who or what the aliens are praying to or invoking or whatever they're doing when they're alone in their cabin with a burning candle, chanting or deep in some kind of trance.Vera Mont

    I think that most movies base their aliens and their customs on human expectations and ingrained beliefs.
    Some scientists seem to believe that the need for the existence of a higher being is innate in humans and many authors try to pass that on to the aliens they create. Others create aliens based on basic fears of humans to make them appear more threatening to the readers or viewers, fear and scary are good for sales.

    Personally I believe that if any alien ever gets here the must be smart enough to realize that there are no higher beings.

    Another question I cannot find an answer to is why space traveling beings are depicted with claws or tentacles that can never have been used to create the spaceships they ride around in.
  • Questioning reality at a young age?
    Has anyone else here had a sense that what they were experiencing in early life wasn't truly real or that it was highly stripped down?

    Or is that natural when one hasn't yet accepting things as they seem to be?
    TiredThinker

    I think that would depend on how old you are. As a kid in the late 50's and early 60's I was out and about in reality, others have mentioned the same thing. We saw reality all the time. The only problem for many was the size of that reality, how far you managed to get from home. Obviously then, where we could not go we did not know first hand. So in some ways it was a limited reality.

    Kids nowadays have the ability to see more through the different internet medias than we ever imagined. But it is always once or twice removed from reality. A lot of kids today have never thought about playing in puddles while it rains, and most parents are too protective to let them even if they did think about it.

    Maybe that is what you mean.
  • Ponderables of SF on screen
    Why do all the deities in the explored galaxy like to be invoked by an open flame?Vera Mont

    What exactly do you mean by "deities"? Could you give an example maybe?
  • Brexit
    Say good morning to your new Prime Minister, lads.javi2541997

    I am still so glad I left England when I did, that place is fucked up.
  • Brexit
    The VAT has to be reduced, and the price of a pint of beer will be £1 from now on.javi2541997

    I remember when we used to go out with three quid and go home very happy (drunk), well fed and sometimes even with a bird after dancing all night. We all got pissed off when the price went up to 10 pence a pint. Them was the days mate....

    Sir2u has to be the next Chancellor of Oxford University to teach Spanish there.javi2541997

    Porque me está molestando con esto, puesto de basura. Dame el puesto de primer ministro y rapidito arreglo el país.
    Y la mitad que van a este universidad ni saben bien el inglés.
  • Two Philosophers on a beach with Viking Dogs
    On the other hand, Plato argues that there cannot be a dog that eats the most, because there is always a dog that eats more.javi2541997

    Does infinity actually mean that there is always one more, or does it just mean the possibility of it?
  • Two Philosophers on a beach with Viking Dogs
    There doesn't have to be any surplus, as this is done once. The task is that the philosopher is to define in some way all the amounts of food and hence all the dogs, that they don't leave some dogs out. As no dog eats the same amount, then it's easy for the goddes to put the dogs in an growing or decreasing line based on their amount of food.ssu

    Ok, so if there is no surplus and no dog that goes without food then there has to be one that will eat more than the rest and one that will eat less.

    The only other option would be an infinite amount of food and an infinite number of dogs. And as you said there is a limited area in Greece, so that does not seem likely.

    And even if there were an infinite number of dogs, there would still have to be the one that eats less than any other dog.
  • Two Philosophers on a beach with Viking Dogs
    I can't fathom it would be for anybody else.ssu

    Maybe I asked the wrong question.
    If all of the dogs are fed, is there anything left over? Until it is time to feed them again at least. Or does the food continue to be 100% even if some of it is removed?
  • Two Philosophers on a beach with Viking Dogs
    And what is "all the food" for the dogs since the food can be compared among the dogs?

    1. There's enough of food, the goddesses made sure about that.
    ssu

    Let me ask you a question. Is the 100% of the food is for 100% of the dogs. It makes no difference the actual quantity of the food, only the correspondence of food to dogs.
  • Two Philosophers on a beach with Viking Dogs
    2. If there was a quantity that could be defined to be different from all other quantities, then there is a dog that would eat this quantity. There are no limitations on the quantities (physical or other), and hence on the dogs.ssu

    Plato is right. By definition #2, there are no physical limitations. A dog that eats the most, and a dog that eats the least implies two physical limits, which violates #2Metaphysician Undercover

    While it is stated that there are no limits, that does not mean that there is no dog that eats the most or the least.
    It is doubtful that the food could be broken down to anything less that a molecule and still be counted as food even though the food is dividable. That would be the food for the dog that ate the least.
    And because the food is dividable to share amongst the little beasts, that would limit the amount that could be eaten by the one that ate the most. No dog could eat all of the food as there would be none for the rest of them.
  • A List of Intense Annoyances
    I found the other one I was looking for.
    http%3A%2F%2Fcdn.taboola.com%2Flibtrc%2Fstatic%2Fthumbnails%2Fda35940346a9b80ebf1b3b7d26141dce.jpeg
  • What would you order for your last meal?
    That reminded me of the joke about the guy that committed murder and went on the run. As he guessed that one day he would be caught and sentenced to death he decide to accustom his body to high voltage electricity. Every day he connected himself to a higher voltage until he managed to withstand over a 100,000 volts.
    When he was caught and tried he was all smiles knowing that if the death penalty failed he would have to be set free.
    The judge sentenced him to death, but the law had changed and now they used a lethal injection. :worry:
  • Mexican Politics and Water Problems
    A similar phenomenon has been taking place around cities like Nairobi, Kenya.BC

    Yep, there are lots of places around the world that this has happened in. It is like a replay of the early industrial revolution in Europe, except that here they are not even modernizing the farms to produce more food.

    I lived in a house with a kitchen sink and an outhouse with cold water only, but the rent was cheap. You got by or you got ahead and moved up to something better.
    Individuals have that opportunity, towns, cities and countries don't really.
  • Mexican Politics and Water Problems
    Do you know the reasons why politicians don’t even bring it up as a goal, even if it’s not 100% possible to provide clean water in all of Mexico?schopenhauer1

    Not exactly sure whether they do or not bring it up in Mexico, I live further south, but here it is now usually local authorities that are responsible for water and sewage. There used to be a national water service but it became unmanageable as so many towns and cities grow. So it is not really a national political issue any more except for rivers and reservoirs.

    Why wouldn’t it be like something akin to a space race or something with lofty goals that maybe would take many years?schopenhauer1

    Politicians come and go every 5 years in Mexico, and spend most of their time trying to get through today to worry too much about tomorrow.
    Yes they pass laws to try and control abuse of the land, forests and water, yes they have sanitation laws, and yes they all sorts of wonderful ideas about how things could be made better.
    But what they don't have are the means and methods to enforce the laws. I don't have any figures for Mexico, but here there are about 250 police officers for every 100,000 people. As you can guess there is not a lot that they can do.

    It would also create jobs, I would imagine. Why would clean water not be a part of any comprehensive national infrastructure plan?schopenhauer1

    Jobs like that cost money that is not available to the authorities whether local or national. People would have to pay more taxes to make the money available. Apart from there being a lot of informal labor that do not pay taxes, corruption also means that those that do, business and industries, find ways to pay less by arguing that the informal commercial section is taking away their business and profits.

    And if you go into the rural areas then there is very little that can be done because there is little money available.
  • Mexican Politics and Water Problems
    Mexico will clean up their water as soon as they solve the cartel problem.BC

    Not to be pessimistic, but I really doubt that.

    Just like a lot of large cities here in Latin America, Mexico cities has grown without a lot of planning happening. Whole areas have been taken over by people moving in from the country to the cities, these areas are nearly always without permissions or environmental studies. Many of them are set up along river banks and most of them do not have running water, electricity nor sewage systems. They also tend to go up the sides of hills that have no other use
    Many of the cities do not have anything more than the old sewage system from when it was a town, and there are lots that do not have even that but depend on septic tanks for each house.
    Because of the rapid expansion of a lot of the cities over the past 50 or so years, many of the newer areas do not have even basic storm drain and those that do are usually just an open ditch alongside the road.

    The cost of implementation of water, sewage and drainage systems for these cities would astronomical and far beyond the capability of many of the local authorities even with the support of central governments.
  • What would you order for your last meal?
    First choice:
    Spam, sausage, Spam, Spam, Spam, bacon, Spam, tomato, and Spam. With toast and a pint of Tetleys best bitter

    Second choice:
    Lobster Thermidor a Crevette with a mornay sauce served in a Provencale manner with shallots and aubergines garnished with truffle pate, brandy and with a fried egg on top and spam.
  • A List of Intense Annoyances
    lm_robotcar_comp-copy.jpg?w=1280&quality=44

    Images like this, with a human like robot doing something as if it is a human. You see images of them sitting in front of a bank of monitors and flying planes.

    The funny thing is that it is never going to happen because it will always be cheaper to incorporate the AI into the system instead of building a separate entity. Why would a robot sit and look at monitors when all of the information could be processed inside a small box? A robot pilot would still have the problem of time lapse because of observation/movement delay, whereas the incorporated AI would not have anywhere near as much.

    Is it just because the want people to accept the fact that there might be robots around soon or is it just that they think people are stupid?
  • Evolutionary roots of envy
    I mean that the TV viewers started to compare themselves with rich TV heroes and feel envy to them.Linkey

    Still works the same, only now there are the kartrashians instead of mobsters. Same thing I suppose though.
  • Evolutionary roots of envy
    As a result, we have the feeling of envy. When we see that other people live better then we, the fact of their comfort makes us unhappy.Linkey

    Some many of those popular people live much better than me, I don't envy them at all. In fact I feel sorry for them having to work so hard to be popular.
  • Changing the past in our imagination
    That makes me think of a common thought exercise used in many college classes. There are 6 people on a life raft with enough provisions for 5. What do you do?Athena

    Nothing, I am not there.
    BUT, they would only have to redistribute the provisions for six and would probably have to prepare to die a day earlier if not rescued.
  • Changing the past in our imagination
    I just looked up how long wheat can be stored and that is 8 to 10 years. I am not opposed to storing food.Athena

    Did you checkout how much certain countries actually hold in reserve? And most grains can last decades in the correct conditions.
  • The News Discussion
    And this is why my former English teacher was right again in his philosophy of "never discussing religion or politics with anyone" no matter how hard I pressed him on the twoOutlander

    I was an English teacher for many years. I used to avoid any discussion about religion, Being the only atheist in a roman catholic school sorts of puts you off things like that.
  • The News Discussion
    The asshole being the deceased?AmadeusD

    Ummm. Maybe that word is to nice for him, after all assholes are useful thing. But anyway I would love to been able to see him shitting himself while the helicopter crashed.
  • The Barber of Seville
    Actually the Barber of Seville is an orthodox Jew and just trims his own beard.

    But I think that the best answer will be that the Barber of Seville is female.

    Now I am going to look at the answer
  • The Barber of Seville
    He shaves himself while looking in the mirror. :cool:
  • The News Discussion
    On a computer screen the format is ok, I never use the mobile for viewing anything unless it is an emergency.

    But I do think he has it about right. I cannot imagine anyone asking for a moments silence for a mass murderer never mind an asshole like that guy.
  • Are War Crimes Ever Justified?
    Are you saying that a woman who has a child can't also have one or more jobs? (Many single and married mothers, in fact, do.) And she's not allowed to sell her lawn mower?Vera Mont

    What the hell are you talking about? where is anything like that mentioned? How is that even part of the discussion?


    (Who said anything about its quality?)Vera Mont

    You did, or do you not remember what you write!

    It's okay for a shopper to pocket the odd can of tuna because prices are too high, and for the seller of alawn mower to lie about its condition to get a better price?Vera Mont

    That doesn't become an ethical consideration, nor yet a change to some different set of ethics, as long as the parking space she's grabbing isn't the handicapped one, and changing checkout lanes doesn't involve shoving in ahead of a doddery senior.Vera Mont

    All I can say now is that you are not even trying to understand, The women's behavior changes depending on the role she is playing. While her morale compass would not let her put anyone in danger, she would not hesitate to grab a spot by going a different route to the rest of the queue.

    They're as available on line to you as they are to me.Vera Mont

    You are the one making broad claims about the laws, it is you that is supposed to show proof of your claims. I have made no claims so I do not have to do anything. So I just just ignore the comment.

    I will no continue to answer your comments, good bye.
  • A List of Intense Annoyances
    I never once initiated a discussion regarding events or persons involved in that conflict.Vera Mont

    Yes, good bye.
  • Are War Crimes Ever Justified?
    This could be true in Canada but I know it's not the case in the US.Benkei

    So maybe Vera can give us a link to the laws.
  • A List of Intense Annoyances
    Continued harping on WWII, as if had been the only notable event in human history.Vera Mont

    From someone that has done more of that than anyone else on the thread about WW2. :rofl:
  • Are War Crimes Ever Justified?
    In your example, if someone else had been convicted of, or is currently on trial for those other murders, you would report your new information to the judge, who would then decide whether to reveal it to the police or counsel for the other accused. Innocence at risk clause.
    Once they're convicted of a capital offense, prisoners are often bribed to reveal previous crimes, but if you get the guy off this one, he also gets away with the others. So you're in a sticky ethical dilemma. Doctors often are, too.
    But it's strictly the job related rules that regulate these things, not one's personal ethics. Basically, when you sign up for the law, or civil service or banking, you promise to leave your own values at home. Some people can go through with that, some can't.
    Vera Mont

    Seriously. i think that you should stop quoting things you see on the screen and do some actual research on the topic. I would certainly like to see those laws.
  • Are War Crimes Ever Justified?
    I know about roles. Most people have more than one role to play in society. What I disagree with is the notion that each role has a different ethical principle or standard. Each role may have different concerns and obligations, different hazards and privileges, but no person has more than one conscience.Vera Mont

    If you had known about roles you would not have made the comments you did about mothers having side hustles as taxi drivers to earn some extra money and selling lawn mowers of dubious quality.

    And if you had actually read and understood my post;

    And this brings us to where a lot of people get confused, your moral compass is the same in each of the roles you play. Your bitching at the super market is caused by the same thing as you wanting a bit more for the lawn mower, looking after yourself and your family.Sir2u

    I think I made it quite clear the morality of the person does not change from role to role, but the ethics attached to that role does. While the mother knows that waiting in line to drop of the kids at school is the correct thing to do she will probably hurry to grab a parking space in the supermarket parking lot. It is a perfectly acceptable thing to do in the supper market, just like changing check out line to get out quicker.