Comments

  • The Social Dilemma
    Yuval Noah Hariri has written a good book on the issue.

    21 Lessons for the 21st Century.

    https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ar44DwAAQBAJ&pg=PT7&source=kp_read_button&redir_esc=y
  • Brexit
    Yesterday the EU rejected the UK request for cars with less than 50% of the parts in them being made in the UK, or the EU, to be classed as made in the UK, therefore being tariff free potentially when exported to the EU. Because the UK could become an offshore assembly hub for non EU parts, with open access to the EU markets. This is probably the death nail of the UK car industry (most of the parts involved are made in Japan, which has just agreed a trade deal with the EU).

    Also today Ursula Von der Layen, formally announced that the EU is taking the UK to court for legislating to break the withdrawal agreement.

    Happy daze.
  • Brexit
    People will start calculating if it's really profitable to work in a crappy job and have less free time, yet have exactly basically same amount of money to spend. Fruit picking is a traditional example of this.

    Yes, I see the problem there. In the UK though social security is so low that it won't have that effect. The problem is more likely going to be due the people just refusing to do a lot of these job, because they think it is beneath them, or they can't do a day's physical work.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    According to polling, almost twice as many Biden supporters as Trump supporters say they’ll vote by mail this year. Over 500,000 mail-in votes have been rejected this year, far outpacing 2016. Perhaps this is why Democrats have pivoted away from championing mail-in voting.
    Sounds like there must be some QAnon (Trump) operatives infiltrating the department that sends out the ballots. It's the only way Trump can contest the election, if he has some evidence to cast doubt on its working properly. Just infiltrate the database which sends them out, find some sacks of dodgy ballots in a dumpster, or something, it's so easy.

    Again contempt for the electoral system, contempt for society, a rat in the Oval Office
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump's comments about voter fraud showed desperation. No one could take that seriously, also it shows contempt laid bare for the electoral process.
  • Brexit
    I see today Boris has marked out our lack of brickies, welders and butchers; and there are calls for the govt to lower the immigration restrictions for these occupations post-Brexit.
    Yes and there are approx 120,000 vacancies in the social care sector and about 40,000 nursing vacancies, not to mention all the crops which need harvesting. Boris should be encouraging the million or three who are going to become unemployed to fill these roles. Plus they don't require a lot of training (with the exception of nurses).

    Brexit is going to provide sufficient vacancies for all the unemployed we will have from Covid, genius!
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    It means that the 2016 election in the US, the EU referendum in the UK, in the same year, gave false results. UK Channel 4 broke the story on Cambridge Analytica in 2017 and exposed the covert manipulation of these elections via Facebook, before most people had realised what was going on.
  • Brexit
    Add there the quite rapid population growth and economic growth being concentrated on few larger cities.
    Yes, this population growth is predominantly from the EU, while there is very little housing being built to house them, no provision of healthcare resources and schools in the areas where they move to. So the local population perceives them as depleting their resources (I wrote at length about this in this thread about 18 months ago). Also, some towns, a number near where I live, now resemble Polish towns. Again the local population is not happy about the way their towns have changed and they feel like they live in a foreign country. It is these demographic forces which have resulted in many of the voters who leant their vote to the Conservatives, voting that way. This is largely why we have Brexit. I notice that now Switzerland has had a vote, due to people wanting to end freedom of movement. The vote was lost, but would have been very disruptive if it had been won.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Everything about Trump is turning out to be fake, hollow, smoke and mirrors.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Nonetheless, one cannot deter someone from voting, or suppress a vote, by showing anti-Clinton ads on Facebook.
    You can, a black guy in Milwaukee admits that he was deterred from voting by a fake anti Clinton add in the report.

    Now we know where the real fake news was.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Excellent investigative journalism by Channel 4 UK tonight revealing voter profiling by the Trump campaign prior to the 2016 election. Targeting 3.5 million Black voters across the US through profiling aided by Cambridge Analytica and Facebook. Each voter identified was targeted to deter them from voting by the use of false and decisive Facebook posts. Racial voter suppression on a mass scale.

    https://www.channel4.com/news/revealed-trump-campaign-strategy-to-deter-millions-of-black-americans-from-voting-in-2016

    Oops, Maw beat me to it.
  • Brexit
    Michael Gove is meeting Barnier today, let's see if he manages to sweet talk him. I suspect he will be laughed at.
  • Brexit
    And yes, it goes through party lines too this class divide. You could see this from Boris Johnson that he acknowledged humbly in his election victory that the conservatives had gotten "labor" votes from labor areas. Usually no politicians would make this kind of remark.
    Yes, but they leant him their support (the majority of them) on condition that he would get Brexit done. They will swing back behind a moderate Labour Party at the next election. So it was not for conservative policies (other than Brexit) that they voted that way, they held their noses when they voted.

    This asset inflation is typical in many countries and a result of the economic and monetary policies implemented after the financial crisis all over the world.
    In the UK it is particularly acute, the housing crisis has been developing for 40 years now with an end to any provision of social housing over this whole period. Not only prices being unaffordable, we have no kerbs on rental fees, which are strangling the young with debt. While many large properties have one or two old people living there. The young are really in a bad place financially and they are wary of trusting the Conservatives when they promise to solve the problem. Because they caused and presided over it for the 40 years.

    I think environmentalism broke through in the 1980's in other countries with Green parties. With tory and labor governments this might not have been so apparent in the UK.
    It was not mainstream in the UK until Greta came along and Sir David Attenborough started speaking out more directly. Now it is widespread and there is little confidence that the Conservatives will make any progress in this direction.

    This might be the real bungle up in British politics. Indeed, it likely would have been a moment for the conservatives to lick their wounds after a long time as the ruling party go to the opposition after everything, but the labor party itself get carried away.
    Yes, there is a deep split in the Labour Party between the moderates and the radicals, which keeps coming to the fore and prevents them getting into office. They need a strong leader to break this curse, Blair did it and many people hope that Kier Starmer can pull it off now. God knows it's needed now.
  • Coronavirus
    Lol, one of my favourites!

    Just what I needed over in the Brexit thread.
  • Brexit
    Uh...the World economy has been in trouble since the financial crisis of 2008, even if China and India have put respectable growth numbers.
    Yes, that doesn't diminish my point though. As always in my comments in the Brexit thread, my focus is on the UK politics from the perspective of an insider who has followed UK politics for a generation. My perspective might have a narrow focus sometimes and ignore wider global trends, but if you understand this you can interpret it this way, as a window into internal UK politics from an insider and draw the implications of wider more global politics from your own knowledge.

    I have explained my reasoning for my conclusions in this thread about a year to 18 months ago. But to recap.

    In the UK, the left right political divide has been, for the last half century or so, in line with a class divide. So the right wing is primarily the middle and upper middle classes, who are privelidged and dominate the establishment, hold all the wealth and to a lesser extent the professions, arts and media. The left wing has been bottom up from the working classes. There is some movement into privelidge and establishment from this social class, but it is limited. Also the majority of the working classes have improved their circumstances over the last generation and become more middle class. But they are still held at arms length by the traditional privelidged classes by an ingrained, largely unconscious, bias and code. Often based on where people live, what schools and colleges they went to etc. This may be the same in other countries, I don't know, perhaps you can help me there, but in the UK it is still very dominant and skews politics towards the right.

    Anyway the financial crisis was blamed on the City of London in the UK, just as much as US banks had been blamed. The spell, the magic of British capitalism was burst, exstinguished, in the minds of many people in the UK and subsequently knowledge of what the privelidged classes in the City were up to is more widely known. Then we had 10years of austerity imposed by the same establishment that was blamed for allowing and benefitting from the conditions which caused the crisis.

    The young grew up during this and are now impoverished by continuing inflation in the housing market, meaning only privelidged young can purchase property*, with the help of their parents. Also they are in debt when they leave university due to having to pay for all their fees and accommodation etc. critically this impoverishment has affected large numbers of the young of the privelidged as well now. This has resulted in an en-mass move to the left among the young, which is also enmeshed in the newly developed ideologies around combatting climate change and protecting the environment. Issues which are largely denied by the privelidged (largely over 50 years of age) establishment, in favour of more free market capitalism.

    Also the Conservative party is not covering itself in glory at the moment and is becoming a laughing stock.

    The problem with our recent election is that the alternative was possibly even more scary than the Conservative party. A Corbyn government would have been a radically left leaning government and there just aren't enough people in the population who could vote for that kind of radical change.


    * this trend is exacerbated by the housing crisis in general in which young who don't own their own house are forced to pay ever increasing rent for small properties. Meaning they can't pay back their higher education debt, or save money for a deposit to buy a house.
  • Brexit
    ↪Kenosha Kid
    We had a similar thing in the UK with Brexit. The leavers won 51:49%. Because David Gammeron was too thickly cut to consider the possibility that the majority might be comparable to the sort of result variance that would be time-averaged out, we were stuck unable to contest what ought to have been a highly contestable result.

    Yes, Cameron was naive, he didn't realise how much anti-EU sentiment had been developing beneath the surface over the previous 12 years. He was Boyed up with the arrogance that he had won the Scottish Independence referendum and would win the Brexit referendum in the same way. There was little thought of losing it and what the consequence would be. It was a fatal flaw to leave to a simple majority, it should have been a super majority of 60%, or more for a win. Once the referendum was called the right wing populist machine went into overdrive and forced the vote through on paranoia, misinformation and false promises.

    Now we have an equivalent to Trump in the UK, with the same worrying trends emerging. Even today it has been leaked that Paul Dacre the disgraced former editor of the Daily Mail, is being groomed for chairman of Ofcom. And a former editor of The Telegraph for director general of the BBC. With Government Ministers on the media this morning saying that it's time for right wing biased media in the UK. This administration is gunning for the BBC in a big way.

    My take on it is that the economy has been in trouble since the financial crisis of 2008. People are starting to think of alternatives to free market capitalism, which has spooked the Conservative base and the big money backers of the party. They have all feathered their nests for a generation and now the rot has set in to the economy and the country, they don't want to give away any of their wealth to help put it right and the younger generation is turning left on mass. The Conservative party is heading for oblivion, which will allow socialists into office. Once that happens the game is up and the wealth will be clawed back for the good of the whole country. The solution in the eyes of these Conservatives is a lurch to the right with maximum acceleration of rightwing ideology and policies to force the country to the right and hoodwink the population into believing it is the only way to govern. It is high stakes and combined with the disastrous Brexit situation there is going to be much gnashing of teeth and upheaval over the next few years.

    P.s. pasted from the Trump thread.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    We had a similar thing in the UK with Brexit. The leavers won 51:49%. Because David Gammeron was too thickly cut to consider the possibility that the majority might be comparable to the sort of result variance that would be time-averaged out, we were stuck unable to contest what ought to have been a highly contestable result.

    Yes, Cameron was naive, he didn't realise how much anti-EU sentiment had been developing beneath the surface over the previous 12 years. He was Boyed up with the arrogance that he had won the Scottish Independence referendum and would win the Brexit referendum in the same way. There was little thought of losing it and what the consequence would be. It was a fatal flaw to leave to a simple majority, it should have been a super majority of 60%, or more for a win. Once the referendum was called the right wing populist machine went into overdrive and forced the vote through on paranoia, misinformation and false promises.

    Now we have an equivalent to Trump in the UK, with the same worrying trends emerging. Even today it has been leaked that Paul Dacre the disgraced former editor of the Daily Mail, is being groomed for chairman of Ofcom. And a former editor of The Telegraph for director general of the BBC. With Government Ministers on the media this morning saying that it's time for right wing biased media in the UK. This administration is gunning for the BBC in a big way.

    My take on it is that the economy has been in trouble since the financial crisis of 2008. People are starting to think of alternatives to free market capitalism, which has spooked the Conservative base and the big money backers of the party. They have all feathered their nests for a generation and now the rot has set in to the economy and the country, they don't want to give away any of their wealth to help put it right and the younger generation is turning left on mass. The Conservative party is heading for oblivion, which will allow socialists into office. Once that happens the game is up and the wealth will be clawed back for the good of the whole country. The solution in the eyes of these Conservatives is a lurch to the right with maximum acceleration of rightwing ideology and policies to force the country to the right and hoodwink the population into believing it is the only way to govern. It is high stakes and combined with the disastrous Brexit situation there is going to be much gnashing of teeth and upheaval over the next few years.

    P.s. I have copied this into the Brexit thread.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Thes guys must be qanon operatives, the're just hiding under a mask of plausible deniability. They know that if they just came right and and said it (about the children farms in tunnels under London and the blood sucking Democrats) we'd laugh them out of Dodge City. They reserve those gory details for the base, who lap it up.
  • The "One" and "God"
    Any time we talk about the One, duality is already on the scene because the intellect is operating. Any object of thought stands against a backdrop of its negation. (Plato alludes to this in Phaedo). The negation of the One is the Nous and the Soul (sort of).

    Yes, I know this, I suppose the way I'm talking is in abstraction when using words and thoughts. I do have other ways of relating to the one more directly.

    I think of one as already actually two, two is actually three because there are two and the some of them which is one, hence there are three. Three is actually four in the same way. The religious cosmogonies seem to see it this way also. So in a sense one becomes three leapfrogging two.
  • The "One" and "God"
    And yet it is. How could it possibly not be?

    Nicely put, it is odd when folk try to say that the one is something else, thereby insisting one is as least two.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    "It's a wonder we can even feed ourselves"
    - Bob Dylan.

    So it's a race to the bottom then. Krishnamurti would be turning in his grave.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    The one thing we know for sure from thousands of years of experience is that sitting with the guru under the pear tree isn't a sufficiently scalable solution.

    Yes, I don't disagree with your thoughts, or Unenlightened's thoughts on the intractable nature of the problems humanity is dealing with right now. Or how mysticism, spirituality, or religious ideologies are unsuitable means to run the world. What I'm getting at is that people who have reached some level of peace and wisdom in themselves (which I expect is a fair few), would be able to steer the course of humanity through the coming difficult period reasonably successfully. Were they to be in positions of power. It is not inevitable that we are going to have a collapse of civilisation during the next few decades, but the way we are going, it is looking that way and the big problems we are going to have to deal with have barely begun, as yet.

    As to the root of the problem, it is not in over population and starvation as Unenlightened suggested. Although that is something which will need to be managed. It is in our systems of government and the way that developments in society and the media has either corrupted, or hollowed out the institutions. To the extent that only despots, fools and clowns are finding their way into positions of power.

    This either has to be corrected somehow, or things are only going to get worse. And I'm sure I don't need to remind you how easily humans turn to conflict and war.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    I was there in the mid 90's when the ascension tapes came out. It was a heady time. I knew Sandy Stephenson who was the leading light in the New Age movement in the UK at the time, so am familiar with the ideology. The way I view and viewed it was that these people and movements were finding ways to express something they had and were experiencing at the time. There was some exploration of consciousness expansion going on, but I suspect no one really had any deep insights but rather found some way that worked for them.

    Personally I took it all with a pinch of skepticism, which I would do with any ideology, as I am only interested in collecting ideas and have mystical approach to the esoteric side, or issues.

    As an overview I see that that movement along with other movements, such as the rapid developments in social media and the adoption and development of virtual living in gaming etc as expressions of some kind of consciousness expansion which we are going through at the moment. Unfortunately, it is coinciding with a time of global turmoil in which the integrity of the civilisation we have built up is at risk and the spectre of natures cure of a pandemic has arisen.

    Would that I could be a fly on the wall with one of those ascended masters right now. It would be an eye opener, I'm sure.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master

    Well if you are not hungry, then hunger is not a problem for you. But it is quite a big problem for a lot of people. But the people in leadership roles is a reflection of the nature of humanity. No one can lead without having followers.
    So if Sargent Bilko became president that would be good for the world because he is a reflection of a part of humanity? You are essentially saying that we've got the governance we deserve. Like the president of Belarus for example. Or the German people were crying out for someone like Hitler at the beginning of the 20th Century.

    I don't see how anything you are saying is addressing the issue I am raising. Other than trying to say that it is pointless to even try, perhaps.
    Everyone agrees about one thing - "it's not my fault". Unfortunately everyone is wrong about that.
    Its like we're on a race to the bottom.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    Humanity has only one problem and that is humanity.
    Yes, that is quite an obstacle. Which is why I said that they might not have an interest, because it is humanity's problem, that they let things take their course.
    but it is an internal problem and a great leader can only make it worse.
    I don't think you can conclude this. The main problem, at the moment is not things like feeding the poor etc. But our systems of political control and the quality of the people in those roles are more of a problem. Anyway, things don't have to be this way and people might initiate change in a more constructive direction, so if the right person gets into the right position they can make considerable changes in the fate of humanity.

    I am leading towards the idea of esoteric thinking, which is engendered in the Theosophical movement. The questioning of what might be going on behind the scenes.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    What did I say about withdrawing from the world? I missed it.
    It is implicit in the instruction given in the quotes from phrophets you have provided.

    I am not referring to removing oneself physically from the world. But, intellectually and psychologically. A process of introversion.

    We could sort all that out for everyone in a year or less. It is a trivial logistical problem of redistributing resources.
    Yes, I agree. Well, are you going to lift a finger, or shall I?

    I jest, but seriously, who is going to provide this redistribution in a timely manner? You see, the fortunes of the human race, are a real time event. They are happening here and now at speed. Even if it is just a logistical problem, if the course of human history is to be steered in a constructive direction, it has to be done now in the moment. If there are ascended masters, prophets out there, now, in this moment. Would they just turn a blind eye to our fate,? or would they take an interest, of some kind?

    Is the plight of humanity of any importance to these prophets? Or is it an irrelevance, because it is a natural process, or something? These are interesting questions.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    Yes,I would agree that Jesus and other masters, even if the idea of ascension is a myth, would certainly wish to help others as compassion was a central message of these teachings.
    Yes, compassion for all beings. Bhuddists strive not to harm any other being, indeed, to help, where they can. In Hinduism, each person seeks to teach and/or spread compassion and wisdom. In Christianity, the redemption, or saving of humanity is more explicit. This implies the helping, the guidance of our fellow man. To bring forth heaven on Earth.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    But the solutions to psychic hunger aren't perfect or permanent. When we're physically hungry we eat something. And then we have to eat again in a few hours. This goes on our entire life, the need to eat never ends. And so addressing physical hunger, and psychic hunger, isn't a glamorous business but instead just routine maintenance of a bodily function.

    Because the readily available solution isn't glamorous, philosophers will likely lose all interest and continue on their becoming trips, to where they already are.
    Nicely put. I would add the idea that it's not just the thinking that causes the psychic hunger in this analogy, but the development of an ego within the personality of the person. This ego requires nourishment as well and tying to the post (discipline) of a reasonable and humble being.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    Yes, it is an unpopular message, and always has been.

    But what you imply is the message is not infact the message. You are confusing the teaching that in order to progress towards personal enlightenmet one must withdraw from the world and find the answer/route internally. With the idea that these ascended prophets have a disregard, or are indifferent to the plight of humanity as a whole. The later does not follow from the former.

    When Jesus states that in order to go with him, one should deny himself, he is referring to the day to day concerns of that individual within the society at large and his internal narrative and concerns. This is what he is asking the disciple to deny, to leave behind. In favour of the cross of redemption. The cross is a complex symbol to unravel, but as it is used here, it is referred to as the burden of the acceptance of the human condition and the suffering entailed in the relinquishing of that by a human, in real time, within a real cultural setting and all that that entails (by implication, that society would inevitably crucify, or perform some equivalent act, on such a person).

    Everyone wants to go up, and no one wants to go down.
    But if humanity is left to go down, the majority will be going down. It seems inefficient to me, when just one person lifting a finger could reverse this.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Perhaps the real problem here is that in a few years whites will be in the minority in the US. More whites are dying than being born.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    "we're dooomed" as said by Frazer in Dad's army.

    I would take issue with your conclusion. On the assumption that these ascended masters are really ascended, which is implied in your comment (unless you are engaging in parody, which is fine with me). Then, one is also accepting a cosmogeny of evolving souls etc etc. I know that the Eastern prophets come across as indifferent to the plight of the ecosystem and by implication the race of humanity in favour of personal enlightenment. I would suggest that this is a naive presumption. Also that Jesus did act in the world and ask people to reform society and by implication to intervene in the management of humanity. Jesus is asking us to lift a finger, to cross the road to help that old lady.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    I wouldn't say that, because duty implies conflict and division. But in this field, if one does not live according to one's understanding, then one hasn't really understood.
    That's not how I was using the word duty, perhaps I should have said ought to.

    Anyway, do you cross the road to help an old lady struggling with her shopping?

    My point is that there are a large number of people who have the (shall I say) wisdom to know how humanity should move forward in a constructive way. Meanwhile humanity is going to hell in a hand cart under the direction, of despots, clowns and idiots. Should these wise folk lift a finger, or just sit there and descend into hell with the rest of them?
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    In answer to the question of whether I I found it fulfilling I think that it enabled me to hold onto my own sanity and I might have otherwise become unwell mentally. Nowadays, I enjoy reading esoteric literature but with an open but questioning spirit.
    I found it useful as an entry point into some of the ideas of Hinduism and Eastern religions in general. Along with a means by which to break free, within my own mind, from the rigid conditioning of the Western narrative. Something very constructive.

    I can't imagine how I would have developed without such an alternative view on the world as presented in our society.

    Also, I find it a useful narrative in discussing mysticism, which is devilishly difficult to discuss in forums like this.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    I don't really read K. any more, because the message is so very simple and all the complications are my own.
    I agree, but is there not a duty for people who get the message to apply it in their lives to some extent? Or more broadly, as we as intelligent beings with agency, can alter the world (ecosystem). Surely some wisdom ought to be applied in the corridors of power, or in the direction of humanity. Or otherwise, surely, we are doomed.
  • Theosophy and the Ascended Master
    While I am not sure that all esoteric systems can be taken literally, I think they do offer an interesting alternative and I keep an open mind towards the idea of spirit guides and the possibility of ascended Masters, who include Jesus, the Buddha and Saint Germain.
    I agree with this, although I think it important not to try to define what is going on behind the scenes, because we cannot know for certain, just what is going on and what, or for why, our existing in this world we find ourselves in has come to pass.

    I have found a problem with exposing esoteric thinking to philosophical scrutiny, because the philosophical process inevitably reduces it to some kind of psychological figment of the human mind. Also that the majority of philosophers seem to have come to the implicit assumption that reality, existence and it's explanations are within the preview of science and scientism. Resulting in any other kind of epistemology being disregarded out of hand as just another figment.

    I would happily discuss this further, while putting this philosophical scepticism to one side for a while.

    Do you think your interest in these areas has enriched your life at all?
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    You have more optimism than me regarding the mental acuity of Americans.
    I was referring to UK folk, I'm already despairing about US folk.
    Exhibit A, above.
    I see it loud and clear.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Just substitute the word Commy for antifa. Those damn Commies coming out of the woodwork.

    It's interesting drawing the comparisons with the UK, the right wing is following the same path, but is a few months behind and the society is not quite so fractured. So it is easier to distinguish the ideology and people who have drunk the cool aid. Because the people who haven't are just normal folk, who are a bit bemused with all these people loosing touch with reality and spouting such nonsense. Their ring leaders are right now trying to paint the Black lives Matter movement in the UK as some kind of antifa organisation. I doubt it will stick though, because everyone knows there is no such animal and the fools who fall for it will become more and more exposed for the fools they are.
  • What are your positions on the arguments for God?
    This truly is the functioning of a backward, primitive species.
    The use of religion by politics was constructive in the development of civilisation. It's perversion into nihilist militant extremism is a recent development, one which will be stamped out I expect.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    They should take a leaf out of our book over the pond works well for us in the UK.
    IMG-9280.jpg
  • What are your positions on the arguments for God?
    With "god did it" and "supernatural magic" anything goes. :sparkle:
    Could literally be raised to explain anything, and therefore explains nothing.
    Might as well be replaced with "don’t know", which incurs no information loss.
    Is not itself explicable, cannot readily be exemplified (verified), does not derive anything differentiable in particular, and has consistently been falsified in the past.
    Literally a non-explanation.
    That's ↑ not a dis/proof, but just explicates the vacuity of such utterings.

    I'm familiar with the arguments against assertions of god did it.

    But you haven't answered my question, is there anything in philosophy which justifies the opinion that there is no supernatural element in our origins?