I think it's mysterious that even with knowledge of all the laws of physics, it seems impossible to decide whether plants can suffer. — SolarWind
They (some at least) have awareness and memory. That's sufficient. I suspect they have that capability. — noAxioms
So you want to be spared: — Roke
Glad you are not living there -- you were just visiting, right? — BC
I can find deteriorating neighborhoods in Minneapolis; you can probably find them in your city, too. — BC
Is the version you've read older or younger? — Dawnstorm
There's a lot I can't say, because there's a lot I don't know. See? For example, I don't know how he framed the list you gave us. — Dawnstorm
Bias is inevitable, and I don't think eliminating bias is even something one should attempt. Especially not in an article that wavers between social and personal, like this one. — Dawnstorm
And I hope you don't think I'm denigrating Don Quixote — Dawnstorm
German translation — Dawnstorm
It's like he's encouraging you to go beyond the well-known and figure out your own canon. — Dawnstorm
Yes, but isn’t that the point? If he were an American, there would be Fitzgerald, Faulkner, Bellow, Melville, Whitman; all exceptional. In fact, one could probably make a list like this composed entirely of Americans. — Tom Storm
Might "a classic" just be called "a great book"? — BC
#5. "A classic is a book which even when we read it for the first time gives the sense of rereading something we have read before."
I like that. — BC
I've never liked Hemingway. — BC
I read Don Quixote, once upon a time. — BC
What about individual poems -- can they be classics along side novels? — BC
"'I'm rereading...', never 'I'm reading...'" — Dawnstorm
I find it more bizarre to see an Italian who doesn't include Virgil and the Commedia. It's like leaving out Shakespeare and Milton in English. — Count Timothy von Icarus
The idea of a “universally agreed upon” classic novel is probably seen as a bit outdated these days. — Tom Storm
Literary value is filtered through culture, history, and personal taste. — Tom Storm
I dislike most of Dostoyevsky I have read, except for his mercifully concise The Gambler - — Tom Storm
Not really. French novels have often been considered masterpieces of world literature, and writers like Voltaire, Balzac, Stendhal, Hugo, Flaubert, Zola, Maupassant, Proust, and Gide usually appear on those venerable lists of the 'greatest writers' of all time. I have read most of these and would consider them very fine, although Proust does bore me somewhat. — Tom Storm
Classics are very much a collective canon; "individual classics" is an oxymoron. — SophistiCat
You mentioned Calvino's bias towards Italian authors. Each culture will have its own version of the literary canon — SophistiCat
Minding is a metacognitive activity (i.e. strange looping process), and not an entity; it is what an ecology-situated, sufficiently complex brain can do, rather than some ontologically separate (e.g. non-physical) or "emergent" woo-stuff. Also: not to be confused with consciousness. — 180 Proof
My father's ancestors were farmers. One of the features of farming in the late 19th into the 20th century is how often farmers moved -- not for better views, but because farms failed financially fairly often. Good land but bad economies. — BC
October 20th, 2015: I remember it well. — Jamal
But I think this latest one is copied from el fin del mundo- it's the exact same town. — Manuel
Had to drop the newest Murakami after reading 30% of the book, his quality has dropped quite a bit since 1Q84, this meditative side is very boring to me. — Manuel
Recognizing it as an industry gives space for discussions about labor rights, safety, and respect, rather than just moral judgment or legal status. — PatriciaCollins
She suggests that one should be careful about taking everything Romans said about sex at face value. Romans, like everybody else, might exaggerate on occasion. (Well, everybody except me and thee.) — BC
They probably did, but while the institution of man/adolescent relationships included a sexual element, it was also a civic mentoring relationship. It existed to reproduce the ruling class. Your local plumber in Athens did not take on an apprentice that included sex on the side. This was a ruling class activity, guided by rules, enforced (more or less) by other members of the elite. — BC
Plato and Aristotle weren't writing for brick layers and plumbers; the Age of Pericles wasn't for the slaves or the free workers. That's pretty much the usual and customary relationship between culture and class throughout history, including the present moment. — BC
The high level of literacy and communication tools today allows for people like you and me (who will always have to work in order to live) to engage in discussions about 'elite topics'. But we aren't members of "the elite" because we lack the wealth, credentials, opportunities, relationships, and so on that characterize elites. We are not "movers and shakers" as the expression goes. The elites have always been the tip of the social pyramid. — BC
We just don't know much about what life was like in Greece and Rome for the vast majority of the population. The classical era's proletariate wasn't the topic of a lot of writing from the period. Alas. — BC
"Pederasty, Eros and Ancient Greece" — BC
What in God's name were they thinking? — BC